Instance-Optimality of Bidirectional Dijkstra on Simple Graphs
We study the shortest-path problem on graphs with positive real-valued edge weights. Given a source vertex $s$ and a target vertex $t$, the goal is to calculate the length of the shortest path from $s$ to $t$. We are particularly interested in instances that can be solved in sublinear time. Recently, Haeupler, Hlad\'ik, Rozho\v{n}, Tarjan, and T\v{e}tek proved that (a version of) the bidirectional Dijkstra's algorithm is instance-optimal on positively weighted multigraphs, both directed and undirected, considering the number of vertices and edges queried by the algorithm. However, multigraphs are not the canonical setting for the shortest-path problem. The problem is typically formulated on simple graphs without loops and parallel edges. They therefore left as an open problem whether bidirectional Dijkstra remains instance-optimal on simple weighted graphs. We answer this question, but for simple graphs, the answer is more complex, depending on the setting. We show that bidirectional Dijkstra is still instance-optimal on simple undirected weighted graphs under the order-oblivious model, where incident edges are given in a random order. In contrast, under the order-dependent model, where incident edges have a given order, we show that bidirectional Dijkstra is not instance-optimal. For simple directed weighted graphs, we show that bidirectional Dijkstra is not instance-optimal under either the order-oblivious or the order-dependent model, being off by a factor of $\Theta(m/n)$ in both cases. We further show that no algorithm can have instance-optimality ratio $o(m/n)$ under the order-dependent model, or under the order-oblivious model when $m=O(n\sqrt{n})$. On the positive side, the above results imply that bidirectional Dijkstra is instance-optimal up to logarithmic factors on all sparse directed and undirected graphs satisfying $m/n=\log^{O(1)} n$.