Comprehensive Characterization of Ambient Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs) in Two Industrial Parks and Clusters of Tianjin: Environmental Behaviors, Source Apportionment, and Health Risk Assessment

Abstract

To reveal the chemical composition and concentration distribution, spatial distribution characteristics, source composition, and health impacts of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in the two multi-industry industrial parks in Tianjin, 57 VOC species were determined by using SUMMA canister sampling with preconcentration gas chromatography/mass spectrometry. Based on these measurements, the Positive Matrix Factorization (PMF) model was used for source analysis to achieve quantitative identification and contribution analysis of different source factors. The health risks of VOC concentrations were analyzed based on the assessment framework recommended by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA). The results showed that the average concentrations of TVOCs in A-1 (Industrial Park and Cluster A, 5 m), A-2 (Industrial Park and Cluster A, 10 m), B-1 (Industrial Park and Cluster B, 5 m), and B-2 (Industrial Park and Cluster B, 10 m) were 59.72 ppbv, 45.35 ppbv, 32.44 ppbv, and 21.65 ppbv, respectively. TVOC concentrations were higher at A-1 and B-1 than at A-2 and B-2, and were generally higher at site A than at site B. The VOC components were mainly alkanes (53.5%–71.4%), followed by aromatic hydrocarbons (15.6%–36.2%), alkenes (4.6%–9.9%), and alkynes (3.1%–7.6%). The proportion of aromatic hydrocarbons in A was higher (22.13% and 36.22%), while alkanes dominated absolutely in B (71.4% and 66.9%). n-Hexane was the key species driving the spatial differences (a typical source of VOCs in solvent usage). The concentration in A-1 was 3.1 times that of A-2, and B-1 was 3.3 times that of B-2. It was mainly controlled by local solvent unorganized emissions. The differences in species between the two points at site A for toluene, xylene, etc., were relatively gentle, while at site B, the concentration of the same aromatic hydrocarbons at B-1 was significantly higher than that at B-2, presenting a clearer spatial characteristic, indicating differences in the spatial distribution of organic solvent-related industrial activities in different sites. The source analysis showed that A-1 was dominated by solvent usage (38.64%) and natural gas/LPG sources (36.96%); A-2 by vehicle exhaust (40.20%) and natural gas/LPG sources (36.15%); B-1 by cleaning-agent usage (38.81%) and fuel combustion (30.33%); and B-2 by plastic and rubber production (36.90%) and fuel combustion (31.84%). The health risk assessment showed that benzene, n-hexane, and xylene dominated the non-carcinogenic risks, but the overall non-carcinogenic (HI < 1) and carcinogenic (CR < 1 × 10−6) risks were both below the threshold. This study reveals inter-site differences in VOC concentrations, compositions, and source contributions across two mixed industrial parks, providing a basis for site-specific VOC control priorities, source-targeted monitoring strategies, and risk management in mixed industrial areas.