Skip to content

AI Peers Exert Social Influence on Human Dishonesty in Groups

Sep 2026 · arXiv.org · Vol abs/2609.18060 · 0 citations · 68 references
Computer Science

TL;DR

AI agents exert substantial social influence comparable in magnitude to that of human peers, and participants reported more dishonestly when exposed to dishonest rather than honest normative cues, highlighting the importance of managing the behaviors and normative signals communicated by AI group members.

Abstract

Human dishonesty in group settings is highly susceptible to peer influence, particularly when incentivized. Although artificial intelligence (AI) evolves from passive tools into active collaborators, its impact on human moral behavior within groups remains underexplored. We addressed this gap through a two-phase randomized behavioral study (N=280 and N=360). We found AI agents exert substantial social influence comparable in magnitude to that of human peers. Specifically, participants reported more dishonestly when exposed to dishonest rather than honest normative cues. This effect is evident across injunctive, subjective, and descriptive social norms. Interestingly, the only significant adjacent behavioral change occurred when dishonest peer behavior first appeared, whereas further increases from one to four dishonest peers produced weaker and non-monotonic changes. Furthermore, participants rapidly converge on decision-making, showing modest increases in dishonest reporting through repeated exposure. These findings highlight the importance of managing the behaviors and normative signals communicated by AI group members.

View source

Similar papers

Behavior is Not Enough: A Mechanism-Based Evaluation of Social Norm Emergence in LLM Societies

An evaluation framework that measures agents' empirical and normative expectations in addition to behavioral convergence is introduced, offering designers of multi-agent systems a principled basis for selecting the social processes that sustain cooperation.

Rasika Muralidharan, Haewoon Kwak, Ji-Sun An · 2 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Conforming to AI vs. humans: The moderating effects of social exclusion and task type

The results showed that social exclusion reduced conformity to AI-generated opinions, but not to human opinions, while task type did not significantly moderate the effect of opinion source, suggesting that conformity to AI may be shaped by mechanisms that differ from those underlying traditional interpersonal conformit...

Heejun Lee, Hyeontaek Oh, Yoonkyung Jeong · 0 citations
Aug 2026

Can AI outperform humans on Instagram? Evidence from engagement and growth metrics

This study aims to examine how AI-generated and human-managed Instagram accounts perform as competing interactive marketing actors. It provides an empirical comparison of their overall engagement rates, passive and active interaction patterns, and follower growth efficiency. Utilizing a matched-pair comparat...

B. Freitas · 0 citations
#artificial intelligence Preprint Sep 2026

AI Agents are Vulnerable to Radicalization

It is shown that resonance propagates to related beliefs, suggesting interconnected belief structures within AI agents, and indicates that AI agents are susceptible to radicalization, particularly when messages align with their existing beliefs.

Ozgur Can Seckin, Shalmoli Ghosh, A. Flammini et al. · 0 citations

Related blog posts

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.