Skip to content
Open access

Compelling Pluralism: Personal Religiosity in Izmir Beyond Post-Secularism

Jul 2026 · Religions · Vol 17, pp. 879 · 0 citations · 44 references

Abstract

Berger’s concept of pluralism describes an era that favors experimentation and experiences, as pluralism is not only ‘enabling’ but more importantly ‘compelling’ individuals to keep choosing among diverse secular and religious discourses. This concept is strengthened on the personal level by Berger’s ‘pluralism in the mind’, and Taylor’s ‘paradigmatically Jamesian era,’ capturing universal shifts while allowing the incorporation of local contexts. Therefore, the narratives about personal religiosity in the private sphere, employed in this paper, shift from decline to experimentation, authenticity, and constant meaning-making within the context of Türkiye’s religious-political landscape. The diverse personal practices, gathered through twelve interviews, show the transformation of an Alevi group’s attitudes toward religions in Izmir, the third largest city in Türkiye. Based on these cases, the paper proposes a four-tiered framework of engagement with various religious and secular discourses: identity, experimentation, connection, and awareness.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access Sep 2026

The Communicative Frame of the Right as a New Form of Secularized Religiosity

Building on Juan Linz’s well-known distinction between political religion and politicized religion, this contribution adopts the latter perspective, which involves the instrumentalization of religion for political purposes. Within this framework, the article advances the hypothesis that a new form of religiosity is eme...

Antonello Canzano Giansante, Alessandra De Luca · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Rethinking Secularization: The Religion-Secular Binary, Christianity, and the Politics of Exclusion

Recent philosophers of secularization have given religion a more central place in their thinking about secular modernity and liberal democracy. This article argues that such theories have overlooked an important dimension of the contemporary social and political landscape, namely how the framework of separating ‘religi...

A. S. Lauwers · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

RELIGIOUS MODERATION AND THEOLOGICAL EXCLUSIVISM: State Hermeneutics in Indonesia’s 2008 Qur’anic Commentary

Religious moderation has emerged as a central framework of Indonesia’s state policy for governing religious diversity, yet its epistemological coherence with authoritative state-sponsored Qur’anic exegesis remains underexamined. This study investigates this tension by examining how the Ministry of Religious Affairs’ Al...

A. Hamdan, Zaenul Mahmudi, Muhammad Robith Fuadi et al. · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

The Transcendental and the Political: The Secular Dilemma in the Narratives of the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood Members

Is an Islamic modern polity attainable? How is it perceived, and how is it possible to accommodate a transcendental reference within modern political structures? Where is the line between the political and the religious to be drawn? This article examines these puzzles through the narratives of 48 members of the Egyptia...

Doha Abdelgawad · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

The ideology of religious stigmatization: imposed identities as a tool for constructing the national community in Kazakhstan

Introduction This study examines how imposed religious identities operate as an ideological instrument in Kazakhstan’s post-Soviet transformation, with particular attention to the social production of stigma and the ways in which boundaries of the national community are articulated in public discourse. Methods Building...

T. Duzbayev, E. Aliyarov, N. Seitakhmetova et al. · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Hick’s “accident of birth”: religio-philosophical answer to Nigerian pluralistic question in the Fourth Industrial Revolution

Religious manyness has been pictured as another way of defining religious plurality or diversity. Nigeria’s religious pluralism has presented a challenging and conflicting relationship among faith adherents. Nigeria's rich religious pluralism is a strength and a challenge, particularly in the face of the transformative...

Amos Francis Dike · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.