Constructing microbiome co-occurrence networks with confidence: A conditional, nonparametric, inference-based approach
TL;DR
A conditional, nonparametric approach based on the scaled expected conditional covariance (SEcov), which allows investigators to construct microbiome networks using statistically interpretable evidence for taxon-pair associations, rather than relying solely on arbitrary correlation cutoffs or regularization tuning parameters.
Abstract
Constructing microbial association networks is a common strategy for exploring relationships among taxa in microbiome studies. Although marginal correlation methods are easy to implement and allow formal inference, they can produce spurious edges driven by indirect associations through other taxa. Conditional graphical-modeling methods aim to recover direct associations, but many rely on Gaussian or linear assumptions and often provide limited uncertainty quantification. We propose a conditional, nonparametric approach based on the scaled expected conditional covariance (SEcov). SEcov measures population-level conditional association by residualizing each taxon with respect to the remaining taxa and scaling the resulting expected conditional covariance. The resulting estimator can incorporate flexible machine-learning methods for conditional-mean estimation and admits asymptotic normal inference, enabling p-values and confidence intervals for taxon-pair associations. We demonstrate through simulation studies that our proposed approach improves network recovery relative to other methods, and we illustrate the new method via construction of a co-occurrence network for the vaginal microbiome during pregnancy. IMPORTANCE High-throughput sequencing has made it possible to characterize microbial communities at large scale, and network analysis is widely used to summarize relationships among taxa. However, networks based on marginal correlations may include indirect associations, whereas many conditional graphical models rely on assumptions that may be difficult to justify for sparse, zero-inflated, compositional microbiome data. SEcov offers a practical alternative by estimating conditional associations nonparametrically and attaching inferential uncertainty to individual edges. This allows investigators to construct microbiome networks using statistically interpretable evidence for taxon-pair associations, rather than relying solely on arbitrary correlation cutoffs or regularization tuning parameters.