Skip to content
Open access

The legal production of “the civilian” in contemporary war

Sep 2026 · Oñati Socio-Legal Series · Vol 16, pp. 2293-2324 · 0 citations · 92 references

Abstract

How is “the civilian” made knowable in contemporary war? This article argues that civilian status is increasingly produced as an epistemic outcome at the intersection of international humanitarian law (IHL) status categories, surveillance governance, and evidentiary/justificatory regimes. Through a socio-legal reading of treaty law, ICRC commentaries, military manuals, civilian-harm mitigation policies, selected jurisprudence, and public justifications, it traces two coupled production loops: pre-strike classification (pattern-of-life inference, metadata, probabilistic thresholds) and post-strike recognition (recording, investigation, secrecy, and narrative closure). The analysis shows how the presumption of civilian status in doubt can be practically inverted by risk-calculus and intelligence “confidence”, while accountability mechanisms can stabilise or erase civilianhood through files, standards of proof, and disclosure practices.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Sep 2026

"The Institutional Production of Ethical War Across Modern Conflict"

"This paper argues that modern warfare operates through an ethical infrastructure that enables, rather than restrains, the use of violence. Contrary to the common assumption that moral frameworks such as Just War Theory function as safeguards against harm, the historical record shows that ethical language, humanitarian...

Katerina Udov · 0 citations
Open access 2026

Civilian control over the armed forces under two conceptions of democracy

In a context marked by democratic backsliding worldwide and the additional pressures that hybrid warfare linked with the war in Ukraine places on democratic governance in European states, the foundations of military subordination to civilian authority warrant renewed scrutiny. Such strains can put pressure on defining...

A. Lucinescu · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

Core principles of civil law in the digital age: Theoretical risks and enforcement solutions

Digitalization is revolutionizing the exercise and protection of civil rights and the allocation of potential risks arising from the use of automated systems. This article examines whether the above changes indicate a humanitarian crisis in civil law or reflect its adaptation to a rapidly digitalizing legal environment...

R. I. Gazizullin, F. Khamidullina · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

The Legal Position of the Geneva Conventions in Resolving Contemporary International Conflicts

This article examines the legal position of the 1949 Geneva Conventions in resolving contemporary international conflicts. It analyzes the Conventions as the central treaty framework of international humanitarian law and evaluates their continuing relevance in international and non-international armed conflicts, asymme...

Isabelle Rochat · 0 citations
Open access 2026

Expropriation and international law

This contribution traces the evolution of international legal protection for foreign-owned property from the late nineteenth century to the present. It begins by examining the pre-1900 era, when private property was largely deemed inviolable and disputes were governed by host-state treatment, before turning to the prin...

Oliver Diggelmann · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.