Integrating rare and common variation in epilepsy genetics: from genetic architecture to penetrance and clinical expressivity

Abstract

Epilepsy genetics has often been interpreted through a useful but simplified dichotomous framework in which severe epilepsies, particularly developmental and epileptic encephalopathies, are attributed mainly to rare, high-effect variants, whereas more common epilepsies are viewed as arising largely from the cumulative effects of common, small-effect variation. Although this framework has been instrumental for gene discovery, molecular diagnosis, and mechanism-based treatment, it does not fully explain incomplete penetrance, intrafamilial phenotypic heterogeneity, or marked differences in severity among individuals sharing the same molecular diagnosis. Evidence from exome sequencing, copy number variant (CNV) studies, and genome-wide association studies increasingly suggests that rare SNVs/indels, CNVs, and common variant should not be interpreted as entirely independent risk sources, but may partially converge on shared genes, pathways, cell types, and neurobiological processes relevant to neuronal excitability, network stability, and seizure susceptibility. Here, we review evidence across epilepsy subtypes, focusing on convergence and divergence across the allelic spectrum, and discuss how polygenic background and other modifiers may influence penetrance and clinical expressivity among carriers of rare pathogenic variants and CNVs. We also consider implications for variant interpretation, genetic counseling, risk stratification, and precision medicine, while emphasizing that most rare–common integrated models remain insufficiently validated for routine clinical decision-making.