Biochar and Sustainable Crop Performance: A Synoptical Review of Its Properties, Agronomic Potential and Constraints

Abstract

Biochar has emerged as one of the most promising nature-based strategies for improving soil quality, enhancing crop productivity and supporting climate-smart agriculture. However, the agronomic performance of biochar remains highly variable because its effects are governed by complex interactions among feedstock characteristics, pyrolysis conditions, soil properties and management practices. This review synthesizes recent advances in biochar research (2019–2026), examining how production variables determine biochar physicochemical properties and how these properties subsequently influence soil functioning, plant performance and long-term agricultural sustainability. The review integrates evidence on feedstock selection, pyrolysis technologies, biochar modification strategies and the relationships between biochar properties and soil physical, chemical and biological processes. Particular attention is given to crop productivity, nutrient use efficiency, stress mitigation, contaminant immobilization, greenhouse gas mitigation and long-term soil resilience. Across the literature, the most consistent agronomic benefits were observed when biochar was applied to degraded or resource-limited soils and integrated with complementary management practices, whereas responses were often limited under fertile soils, low application rates or short experimental periods. Rather than identifying a universally superior biochar, the evidence indicates that agronomic performance depends on matching biochar characteristics to specific production objectives and environmental conditions. Based on these findings, this review proposes a transition from generalized biochar application towards optimized deployment strategies supported by standardized characterization, long-term multi-site validation and integrated environmental and economic assessments. This synthesis provides a comprehensive framework for guiding future research and facilitating the effective implementation of biochar within sustainable and regenerative agricultural systems.