Sep 2026· International Journal For Multidisciplinary Research· 0 citations· 15 references
TL;DR
A formal human-AI Collaborative Problem-Solving (HACPS) model is presented, which proposes and empirically tests five falsifiable and explicit statistical hypotheses for task partitioning of decision sub-tasks between human and machine agents based on their comparative strengths.
Abstract
While Artificial Intelligence (AI) can now rival or surpass man in performing broad classes of data-intensive tasks such as narrow decision-making and calculation, complex, real-world decision-making, which requires case-dependent understanding, ethical values and creativity—hallmarks of human reasoning—remains exclusive to human intelligence. This paper presents a formal human-AI Collaborative Problem-Solving (HACPS) model, which proposes and empirically tests five falsifiable and explicit statistical hypotheses for task partitioning of decision sub-tasks between human and machine agents based on their comparative strengths. It employs a mixed-methods design, including a 214-practitioner structured survey of practitioners in the healthcare, financial, and technology domains; a controlled between-subjects decision-simulation experiment (N = 96, 4 conditions) to see if there is a significant difference in decision accuracy, decision time, and calibrated trust by experimental condition (Hypotheses 1–3, formal testing via one-way ANOVA, Tukey's HSD); and the qualitative analysis of themes from interviews with practitioners (N = 18) to test whether the underlying complementary principle is consistent—AI-led task ownership is significantly higher in analytical/data-intensive stages of the pipeline than in judgment/ethical stages (Hypothesis 5, formal testing via a paired-sample t-test). Results of all five hypotheses revealed positive. The Collaborative condition achieved statistically higher mean Trust (6.3/7) and decision accuracy (91%) compared to the other conditions (Human-only, AI-only, sequential Human-AI); decision time decreased by 52% and decision quality increased by 26 percentage points across eight cycles of collaboration (linear trend, r²> .97, p<.001); and AI-led ownership was about 52 percentage points higher at analytical stages versus judgment stages (t(213)≈50, p<.001), statistically confirming the complementarity principle. The paper includes the results of the statistical analysis used to arrive at the conclusions, with formulas and worked calculations provided as such, and introduces the validated, reusable framework, an empirically contingent task-allocation matrix, and a research agenda for scaling the human-AI collaboration to high-stakes organizational decision situations.
This systematic literature review critically examines AI delegation, where analytical or decision tasks are transferred to AI, and AI augmentation and proposes a contingent collaboration framework in which decision quality depends on matching AI engagement mode to task characteristics, human expertise, and governance c...
Margret Yusuf Malgwi, Z. Mohammed, Caleb Markus· International journal of res...· 0 citations
A validated, practitioner-usable framework for calibrating the degree of AI autonomy granted to decision workflows against the governance capacity of the organization is contributed, and offers implications for management education, internal audit, and enterprise risk functions responsible for overseeing algorithmic de...
P. Amutha, M. Bhuvaneswari· International Journal of Res...· 0 citations
It is argued that treating the human and the model as a single joint cognitive system is the central design principle for the next generation of decision systems.
Ashore-Onisemo Funmilayo· INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SOC...· 0 citations
A systematic literature review analyzing 111 papers from scientific databases on integrating AI with MCDM/A methods offers both a conceptual consolidation for scholars and a structured foundation for the design of next-generation, human-centered intelligent decision support systems (IDSS).
Bruno Cicciú, E. Frej, A. D. de Almeida· IMA Journal of Management Ma...· 1 citation
Overall, the study demonstrates that AI can be optimized in HR decision-making processes through ethical governance AI practices and human review, which includes the mediating role of ethical AI practices and the moderating role of human monitoring of AI-driven automated HR processes.
Manoj Varghese, Umesh Sharma· KVM Research Journal· 0 citations
A fully on-premise clinical agent that couples local operational control with a multi-perspective reliability framework to support selective autonomy is developed and evaluated, supporting a practical framework for institutionally governed clinical agents.
Li Zhang, G. Wölflein, Dyke Ferber et al.· Nature Medicine· 6 citations
We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads.
See our Cookie Policy.