Skip to content
Open access

The Moral Law Within You

Sep 2026 · Canadian Journal of Philosophy · 0 citations · 16 references

Abstract

Stephen Darwall argues that the conditions of the possibility of addressing demands second-personally entail a commitment to Kantian moral principles. He also argues that previous attempts to vindicate Kantian morality, as a necessary presupposition of agency, have failed. I defend both of Darwall’s arguments against recent objections. But my replies help to bring out a dilemma: either Darwall’s account collapses into previous versions of Kantianism, or it renders morality problematically contingent. I reject the first horn, and then argue that the contingency worry is either not as serious as it seems or affects other versions of Kantianism more severely.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access Aug 2026

The Motive of Duty and Kantian Moral Worth

In this article, it is argued that action from duty has special moral worth on Kant's account because (i) it is an instance of good willing, and (ii) the good will is the only unconditional good. This is used to argue, contrary to various commentators, that Kant's doctrine of moral worth is central, not only to Kantian...

Samuel Kahn · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Justification to Others Is Authorization by Non‐Rejectable Principles

A compelling idea in ethics is that right and wrong is a matter of one's choices being justifiable to others. Contemporary contractualism in particular takes this idea as a starting point. There are, however, different ways to articulate the compelling idea within a contractualist theory. In this paper, I discuss thr...

Per Algander · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Resistance and Racism: On Moral Psychology and Moral Incentive in Nonideal Circumstances

A Kantian reconstruction of racialized moral psychology can illuminate the late Charles Mills’s account of white complicity. Unfortunately, philosophers have comparatively less to say about the incentive structure of the oppressed to participate in the systems that oppress them. Drawing on W. E. B. Du Bois’s notion o...

Elvira Basevich · 0 citations

: THE

R. Perrin · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

What’s unfair about resultant moral luck?

A popular reason for denying resultant moral luck has to do with its alleged unfairness. In this paper, I argue that although two existing objections against the unfairness argument are unsuccessful, it ultimately fails. First, I criticize the objection that the unfairness argument commits a category mistake. Second,...

Anna Nyman · 0 citations
Open access 2026

(What) Does the American Right Think?

This article considers the ongoing culture wars in American higher education as an occasion to think about the durability of xenophobic worldviews. Straining against the notion that right-wing politics is fueled primarily by the resentments of those left behind by decades of inequality under neoliberalism, it suggest...

Anirban Gupta-Nigam · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.