Skip to content
Open access

Metacognitive Blindness in Mathematical Problem-Solving: An Analysis of Junior High School Students on Function Relations

Sep 2026 · Jurnal Pendidikan MIPA · Vol 27, pp. 1764-1785 · 0 citations · 33 references

Abstract

This research is based on the importance of mathematical problem-solving skills as a fundamental competency that students must master. However, PISA results show that Indonesian junior high school students' problem-solving skills remain relatively low. One suspected factor contributing to low problem-solving skills is metacognitive failure in the form of metacognitive blindness, a condition in which students are unaware of mistakes in the problem-solving process. This study aims to analyze junior high school students' problem-solving ability in function relations material, examined in the context of metacognitive blindness. The research used a qualitative, descriptive approach. The study subjects were grade VIII junior high school students selected using purposive sampling. Data collection was carried out through problem-solving ability tests, structured interviews, and documentation. Problem-solving skills were analyzed based on Polya's four steps: understanding the problem, planning the solution, executing the solution plan, and re-examining the results obtained. Metacognitive blindness is identified through three types of red flags, according to Goos: lack of progress, error detection, and anomalous results in each problem-solving phase. The findings reveal that all five subjects experienced metacognitive blindness, with error detection being the most dominant red flag. Students demonstrated procedural competence without metacognitive awareness, as evidenced by Faizan, who achieved the highest score (58) yet remained unable to detect anomalous results. The study concludes that metacognitive blindness significantly contributes to low problem-solving performance, and this condition persists even when students work on structured, routine problems. These findings imply that explicit metacognitive scaffolding should be implemented across all achievement levels, not only for low-performing students, as procedural fluency can develop independently of metacognitive competence. Keywords: problem-solving ability, metacognitive blindness, function relations, polya steps, red flag goos.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Review Open access Oct 2026

Student Teachers’ Metacognitive Awareness and Perceptions of Problem-Solving Ability

Metacognitive awareness, defined as the ability to plan, monitor, and evaluate one’s own learning, plays a crucial role in problem solving. It enables individuals to determine not only which strategies to use but also when and how to apply them effectively. This study aimed to examine the relationship between student t...

G. Demircioğlu, Mustafa Yadigaroğlu · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Students’ Critical Thinking in Solving Mathematical Literacy Problems Based on Mathematical Ability

Critical thinking helps students analyze information, reason logically, and develop appropriate solutions. However, difficulties still arise when students are confronted with complex problems, particularly those involving mathematical literacy. This study aimed to describe students’ critical thinking in solving mathema...

Saniaturochmah, Susanah, Lestariningsih · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

The Effect of Creative Problem Solving and Problem-Based Learning Models on Students' Mathematical Problem-Solving Ability

Mathematical problem-solving ability is one of the essential competencies in mathematics learning. However, this ability remains relatively low, largely due to teacher-centered instruction that leaves students insufficiently active and under-trained in solving mathematical problems. This gap highlights the need for lea...

Rizkiana Salfa Khanifah, N. Agustyaningrum, M. D. Pamungkas · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Remedial Mathematics Sessions: A Strategy to Enhance the Problem-Solving Skills of Grade 4 Learners

This study investigated the effectiveness of structured remedial mathematics sessions in enhancing the problem-solving skills of Grade 4 learners at Malilion Elementary School during the school year 2025 – 2026. Based on Polya’s Four Steps of Problem Solving (Understanding the problem, devising a plan, carrying out the...

Ariana Lopez, Victor Aban · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

Problem-Based Learning Assisted by Student Worksheets to Improve Mathematical Problem-Solving Skills of Primary School Students

Mathematical problem-solving is a foundational competency in elementary education, yet many fourth-grade students continue relying on procedural, drill-oriented strategies rather than systematic reasoning when facing non-routine problems. This study aimed to describe the implementation of a Problem-Based Learning (PBL)...

Nurlina Maharani, W. Wuryandani, Anwar Novianto · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Exploring students’ metacognitive processes in scaffolded integration problem solving

Background: Integration techniques are fundamental to advanced mathematics, yet students frequently encounter difficulties in recognizing problem structures, selecting appropriate integration methods, and regulating their problem-solving processes. Scaffolding may facilitate these processes by supporting students’ meta...

S. Maslihah, Kartono, Wardono et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.