Anterior temporal lobes show route-dependent sensitivity to conceptual specificity: Evidence from MEG and EEG

Abstract

Understanding how the brain represents meaning at different levels of specificity, from general categories (bird) through combined phrases (nocturnal bird) to specific exemplars (owl), is a central question in semantic cognition and its disorders. The anterior temporal lobes (ATL) have been implicated in both activating stored conceptual representations and combining them, yet whether these two routes to conceptual content engage the ATL in the same way remains an open question. We recorded concurrent MEG-EEG from 36 participants reading 100 conceptual triads varying parametrically in specificity: general words (bird), adjective-noun phrases (nocturnal bird), and specific words (owl). Source analyses revealed a non-linear pattern in bilateral ATL (400-520ms): high-specificity concepts elicited greater activity than both low-specificity words and mid-specificity phrases. Bilateral inferior frontal cortex showed this effect with similar timing (430-630ms). N400 amplitude and ATL source activity showed a functional dissociation in their sensitivity to word frequency, ruling out a purely frequency account of the ATL and IFC effects. Results imply that accessing high-specificity concepts requires individuating stored representations among competitors, whereas phrases construct meaning through a different route. These findings extend the unified semantic hub account by revealing that computational operations within the ATL vary depending on task and stimulus demands.