Effectiveness of Argument-Driven Inquiry Combined with Peer Assessment in Developing Epistemic Cognition and Laboratory Report Writing Skills in General Chemistry: A Randomized Cluster Trial
Sep 2026· International Journal of Educational Sciences and Arts· Vol 5, pp. 89-116· 0 citations
Abstract
We ran a cluster-randomized controlled trial with 228 undergraduate general chemistry students, separating what Argument-Driven Inquiry (ADI) and structured peer assessment each contribute alone, and what they contribute together, to epistemic cognition and laboratory report writing quality. Randomization was at the section level. Twelve laboratory sections went to one of three conditions: ADI only (n = 79), traditional cookbook-style instruction (n = 77), or ADI with structured peer assessment (ADI+PA; n = 72). Writing quality was scored on a six-dimension analytic rubric; for epistemic cognition we adapted a scenario-based instrument from Barzilai and Weinstock (2015). In two-level hierarchical linear models with Kenward–Roger small-sample corrections, ADI+PA students scored significantly higher than both comparison groups on epistemic cognition at posttest (g = 1.48, 95% CI [0.89, 2.07], p < .001), and five weeks after the intervention ended that advantage, attenuated by then, was still present. Writing quality followed the same ordering (ADI+PA > ADI > Traditional), with especially large effects in claim quality and counter-argument consideration. Causal interpretation is constrained, though, by several methodological caveats: instructor–treatment confounding, rubric familiarity effects, and time-on-task differences we did not control. Across sessions, qualitative discourse analysis of the peer assessment dialogues traced a progressive shift away from surface-level comments toward substantive epistemic engagement. Pairing ADI with peer review may therefore be synergistic, but replication with crossed instructor designs and larger cluster counts is needed before these estimates can be confirmed.
A structured, seeded review of 24 focal empirical publications, finding no validated individual-level instrument in the focal corpus that tests the full combination of agent scope, permissions, recovery, state isolation, independent review, and evidence-based closure.
The growing use of generative AI writing assistants, such as ChatGPT, in ESL/EFL academic contexts has sparked debate about their influence on self-regulated learning (SRL). This systematic review examines 41 empirical studies published between 2021 and March 2026 to evaluate how university students engage with AI tool...
J. Indongo, S. Ithindi· International journal of soc...· 0 citations
Effective academic writing requires more than grammatical accuracy; students must also organize ideas clearly, use language correctly, communicate efficiently, and sustain reader engagement. This study examined changes in the writing performance of second-year Bachelor of Science in Information Technology (BS-IT) stude...
Kent Leo Estaura, I. Laid· Psychology and Education: A...· 0 citations
This study examined how Moodle-based continuous assessment tasks associate with undergraduates’ metacognitive engagement in English for Specific Purposes (ESP) reading in a first-year engineering course at a Sri Lankan public university. It used a single-case study design, treating a public university’s ESP reading mod...
A. Karunarathne· Journal of Innovative Practi...· 0 citations
Metacognition has informed research on second and foreign language (L2) learning for three decades, while AI tools have supported such learning for nearly as long. Yet, no review has examined how the field conceptualises and measures metacognition under AI mediation. This systematic review identified 60 eligible studie...
Hong Yi, Qiang Chen, Zhuo Wang· Journal of Intelligence· 0 citations
Narrative writing is an important component of English language learning, yet many grade 6 students experience difficulty generating ideas, organizing events, elaborating characters and settings, and using language accurately. This classroom action research examined the use of Design Thinking Cycle to support narrative...
Chimi Wangmo· International Journal For Mu...· 0 citations
We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads.
See our Cookie Policy.