Skip to content
Open access

ISLAMIC LOGIC (MANTIQ) AS A FRAMEWORK FOR CRITICAL THINKING IN THE TEACHING OF ISLAMIC AKIDAH AT SECONDARY SCHOOLS: AN ANALYSIS OF CURRICULUM STANDARDS (DSKP) AND TEXTBOOKS

Aug 2026 · International Journal of Islamic Studies · Vol 35, pp. 13-22 · 0 citations · 9 references

Abstract

This study analyses critical-thinking demands in the Islamic Aqidah component of Form Four and Form Five Islamic Education and examines the potential of Islamic logic (mantiq) as a framework for structuring the reasoning processes required in its teaching. A qualitative content-analysis design was employed, focusing on the Curriculum and Assessment Standard Document (DSKP) and the Form Four and Form Five Islamic Education textbooks, limited to the Aqidah component. Academic literature on critical thinking, Islamic Education and mantiq was used to support interpretation. The units of analysis included learning standards, performance standards, lesson content, learning activities, cognitive verbs and textual demands for reasoning and argumentation. The findings show that the DSKP and textbooks already provide clear space for critical thinking through demands such as applying, analysing, evaluating, formulating conclusions, relating concepts to life, comparing positions and providing justification. However, these documents primarily specify expected cognitive outcomes and learning activities rather than an explicit reasoning framework that systematically guides students from concept formation to truth evaluation, the use of evidence, argument construction and conclusion. In this context, the functions of tasawwur, tasdiq and istidlal demonstrate a meaningful correspondence with these reasoning demands. The study therefore proposes mantiq not as a replacement for Higher Order Thinking Skills (HOTS), but as a complementary reasoning framework rooted in the Islamic intellectual tradition that has the potential to make critical thinking in Aqidah teaching more systematic, evidence-based and epistemologically coherent. Further empirical research is required to evaluate its effectiveness in classroom practice.AbstrakKajian ini menganalisis tuntutan pemikiran kritis dalam bidang Akidah Pendidikan Islam Tingkatan 4 dan Tingkatan 5 serta menilai potensi ilmu mantiq sebagai kerangka yang dapat menyusun proses penaakulan dalam pengajaran Akidah Islamiah. Kajian menggunakan pendekatan kualitatif dengan reka bentuk analisis kandungan terhadap Dokumen Standard Kurikulum dan Pentaksiran (DSKP) serta buku teks Pendidikan Islam Tingkatan 4 dan Tingkatan 5, dengan analisis yang dihadkan kepada bidang akidah sahaja. Literatur akademik berkaitan pemikiran kritis, Pendidikan Islam dan ilmu mantiq digunakan sebagai sokongan interpretasi. Unit analisis meliputi Standard Pembelajaran, Standard Prestasi, kandungan pelajaran, aktiviti pembelajaran, kata kerja kognitif serta tuntutan penaakulan dan penghujahan yang dapat dikenal pasti secara tekstual. Dapatan menunjukkan bahawa DSKP dan buku teks telah menyediakan ruang yang jelas bagi pemikiran kritis melalui tuntutan mengaplikasi, menganalisis, menilai, merumus, menghubung kait, membandingkan dan memberikan justifikasi. Walau bagaimanapun, dokumen tersebut lebih banyak menetapkan hasil kognitif dan bentuk aktiviti yang perlu dicapai berbanding menyediakan kerangka penaakulan yang secara eksplisit membimbing murid daripada pembentukan konsep kepada penilaian kebenaran, penggunaan dalil, pembinaan hujah dan penghasilan kesimpulan. Dalam konteks ini, fungsi tasawwur, tasdiq dan istidlal menunjukkan kesepadanan yang bermakna dengan tuntutan penaakulan tersebut. Oleh itu, kajian ini mencadangkan ilmu mantiq bukan sebagai pengganti Kemahiran Berfikir Aras Tinggi (KBAT), tetapi sebagai kerangka penaakulan pelengkap berasaskan tradisi intelektual Islam yang berpotensi menjadikan penerapan pemikiran kritis dalam pengajaran Akidah lebih tersusun, berasaskan dalil dan selaras dengan epistemologi Islam. Kajian empirikal lanjutan diperlukan untuk menilai keberkesanan kerangka ini dalam amalan bilik darjah.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Review Open access Oct 2026

Higher-Order Thinking in Islamic Education: Examining Teachers' Instructional Practices, Assessment, and Implementation Challenges

Although Higher-Order Thinking Skills (HOTS) are mandated by Indonesia's Merdeka Curriculum, their integration into Islamic Religious Education (IRE) remains poorly documented, particularly in pesantren-based schools where religious mastery has traditionally been prioritized over analytical reasoning. This study descri...

Kania Afra Afifah, Arif Khoiruddin, Amik Nadziroh · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Reconceptualising Pedagogical Content Knowledge (PCK) for Islamic Education: A Theoretical Framework for Integrating Arabic Linguistic Proficiency and Instructional Design

Islamic Religious Education is a complex phenomenon that bridges the theological, jurisprudential, historical and ethical terrains. Although Pedagogical Content Knowledge (PCK) has been the standard way to connect content knowledge and pedagogical content knowledge, the concept is often used in Islamic studies without...

A. Nasirudeen, Lukman Alawi Ishaq · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

The Relevance of the Double Movement Concept in Developing Critical Thinking Skills in 21st Century Islamic Education

The development of critical thinking skills has become an essential requirement in 21st-century Islamic education, particularly in responding to complex social changes, rapid technological development, and global challenges. However, Islamic education is still often characterized by textual, memorization-oriented, and...

Arina Maemanah, P. Rahma, Shakila Kausar et al. · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

The Concept of Educational Learning in Islamic Education: An Examination of the Thought of KH. Hasyim Asy'ari

This study aims to analyze the concept of educational learning in KH. Hasyim Asy'ari's thought and examine its relevance to contemporary Islamic education. Employing a qualitative descriptive approach through library research, this study utilizes Adāb al-‘Ālim wa al-Muta‘allim as the primary source, supported by releva...

A. Rizki, Warul Walidin, M. Makhsin et al. · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Constructivist Learning in Indonesian Islamic Boarding Schools: A Critical Discourse Analysis of English Lesson Plans

Jean Piaget’s constructivist theory emphasizes active knowledge construction, yet its application in Indonesian Islamic Boarding Schools (IIBS) remains limited. This phenomenological case study examines how constructivist principles are integrated into IIBS English lesson plans using a critical discourse analysis appro...

Deni Mustopa, Mochamad Nursalim, Andi Kristanto et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.