Skip to content
Review Open access

A systematic review of algorithmic power, economic dependence, and the epistemology of freedom in platform work

Sep 2026 · Journal of Economic Epistemology and Philosophy · Vol 1, pp. 86-114 · 0 citations · 119 references

TL;DR

This article separates first-order discretion (choosing when to work and which tasks to accept) from second-order control (the capacity to know, contest, exit, and collectively shape the rules), and proposes an agenda for measuring second-order control.

Abstract

Platform companies present the freedom to choose when to work as the defining virtue of gig labor, and labor economists have priced that flexibility. Yet workers’ income and access to tasks are governed by algorithmic assessments they can rarely see or contest. This article asks whether temporal flexibility suffices to call the platform–worker relation free. Following SPAR-4-SLR and PRISMA 2020, we analyze 95 studies (2015–2026), identified through AI-assisted retrieval from Scopus, citation chasing, and targeted searches, using critical interpretive synthesis. The evidence base is expanding rapidly but is epistemically segregated: psychometric studies, all published since 2024, recast algorithmic power as perceived job characteristics; legal scholarship proceduralizes it as information and review rights; and econometric valuations of flexibility are conditional on rules that platforms write and revise. We therefore distinguish first-order discretion (choosing when to work and which tasks to accept) from second-order control (the capacity to know, contest, exit, and collectively shape the rules). Republican non-domination, the capability approach, and Islamic contract ethics converge, from different foundations, on four requirements: knowable rules, contestability, viable exit, and collective voice. Islamic contract ethics contributes the concept of relational gharar, excessive uncertainty located in the rules governing a relationship rather than in single transactions. We use this framework to assess ILO Convention No. 193, the EU Platform Work Directive, and Southeast Asian regimes, and we propose an agenda for measuring second-order control.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access Oct 2026

Shaping the future as we bet

The rapid ascent of decentralized prediction platforms such as Polymarket signals more than a regulatory or financial controversy. This article argues that while prediction platforms represent a hyper-concentrated, automated case study, they instantiate a broader infrastructural condition of late technocapitalism: the...

M. Garasic · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

The Speed of Internationalization: A Systematic Review, Integrative Framework, and Research Agenda

The speed at which firms internationalize has moved from a peripheral curiosity to a central construct in international business research, yet the literature remains fragmented across conceptual definitions, measurement traditions, and theoretical explanations. This review synthesizes 30 years of scholarship on interna...

Zhi-Peng Chen · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Enforcing Competition Law in the Digital Era: Addressing Algorithmic Opacity and Market Power

This research examines the role of algorithms in determining competition in digital markets. It concentrates on the effects of algorithmic systems on the setting of prices, ranking of search engine results, allocation of resources, and consumer behavior. It examines the issues affecting digital competition due to the l...

H. Fawzy · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Mapping Price, Performance, and Fairness Research: A Bibliometric Analysis and Knowledge Structure (2015–2026)

The evolution of the digital economy and artificial intelligence (AI) algorithms has shifted the perception of price fairness encompassing price, performance, and fairness from conventional transactions toward the ethical transparency of digital systems. Utilizing a bibliometric analysis (via VOSviewer and Bibliospy) o...

Yusnidar, Muhammad Pringgo Prayetno, Arih Dwi PRihastomo et al. · 0 citations
Open access Nov 2026

Deciding in the shadow of the state: when regulatory logic collides with market logic

Capital allocation models treat planning inputs as market-governed, even when they originate from political authority. Written for The Practice of Making Decisions section of Management Decision, this paper develops a three-phase response: classify each input, stress test it against a change of authority and design...

Amadeus Gabriel · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.