Skip to content
Open access

Pragmatic vs. naive genetic instrument selection in Mendelian randomization studies: a practical guide

Aug 2026 · medRxiv · 0 citations
Medicine

TL;DR

It is demonstrated that universal reliance on default LD clumping parameters can lead to suboptimal instruments, and a pragmatic framework for instrument selection based on empirical evaluation of strength metrics is proposed, improving the robustness and transparency of MR analyses across different exposure types.

Abstract

Mendelian randomization (MR) is widely used to infer causal relationships using genetic variants as instrumental variables, yet the selection of genetic instruments is not always given sufficient attention. Many MR studies rely on default linkage disequilibrium (LD) clumping parameters (r2 <0.001, 10,000 kb), as implemented in commonly used tools, without assessment of their suitability for specific exposures. We investigated whether this approach yields optimal instruments or whether a more pragmatic strategy yields stronger instruments. Using UK Biobank data, we examined three distinct exposure types-circulating amino acids, body mass index (BMI), and major depressive disorder (MDD). For each phenotype, we systematically varied LD clumping thresholds (r2 and genomic distance) and evaluated each instrument via both their average strength (F-statistic) and total strength (R2). Across all phenotypes, optimal instruments differed from default parameters and varied by exposure. For amino acids and BMI, more stringent LD thresholds (r2=0.00001) combined with larger clumping windows improved instrument strength, whereas for MDD, a highly polygenic, binary trait, smaller windows with stringent r2 maximized variance explained while maintaining F-statistics above the desired threshold (>10). Notably, increasing the number of SNPs did not consistently improve instrument quality, highlighting a trade-off between instrument strength and potential pleiotropy. We demonstrate that universal reliance on default LD clumping parameters can lead to suboptimal instruments. We propose a pragmatic framework for instrument selection based on empirical evaluation of strength metrics, improving the robustness and transparency of MR analyses across different exposure types.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Preprint Sep 2026

Towards more plausible point-identifying assumptions in two-sample Mendelian randomization

It is shown that summary-level homogeneity is implied by the following conditions: the causal effect is additive linear, but not necessarily constant across, all strata of the population; and uncorrelatedness between heterogeneity in the causal effect and in the association between each genetic variant and the exposure...

F. Hartwig, N. Davies, George Davey Smith · 2 citations
Review Open access Oct 2026

Refining Genetic Instruments for Dietary Intake Mendelian Randomization Using Phenome‐Wide Association Studies

A scoping review of the literature on dietary intake MR studies revealed that only 20% of studies used an IV with functional plausibility, and future work should focus on identifying functional variants impacting dietary behavior.

Kristen J. Sutton, Julie E. Gervis, Moomal Jatoi et al. · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Valid Inference for Two Sample Summary Statistics Mendelian Randomization

Mendelian randomization (MR) studies increasingly rely on summary statistics from genome‐wide association studies (GWASs). However, current summary‐data methods treat marginal GWAS effect estimates as independent across instrumental single‐nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), which holds only when the SNPs have no effect....

Kai Wang, Grace Z. Wang · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Deviations from genetic additivity driven by rare variants at biobank scale

It is shown that many complex traits show partial recessivity, reconciling conflicting inheritance patterns in the literature, and that joint two-degree-of-freedom models substantially improve statistical power when the underlying trait is partially recessive.

Frederik H. Lassen, S. S. Venkatesh, N. Baya et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

Polygenic risk scores in human genetics for study design discovery and translation

This review outlines four major PRS-informed design strategies: tail sampling based on PRS extremes; discordance sampling based on mismatch between phenotype and PRS-implied risk; conditional and stratified genome-wide association analyses using PRS to adjust for / partition background risk; and residual phenotype anal...

Hui-Qi Qu, H. Hakonarson · 0 citations
Oct 2026

Identifying Potential Drug Targets for Treating ADHD From a Genetic Perspective: A Mendelian Randomization Study.

Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is a chronic neurodevelopmental disorder. Current pharmacological treatments have limitations, highlighting the need for new therapeutic targets. Using two-sample Mendelian randomization with cis-expression quantitative trait loci from the eQTLGen Consortium (31,684 indiv...

Pei Pei, Shu-Wen Lu, Wei-Jie Yu et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.