2026· Scientific Papers of Silesian University of Technology Organization and Management Series11111111· 0 citations
TL;DR
The proposed methodology may support HR managers in selecting and implementing AI-based recruitment systems by enabling a structured assessment of system functionalities, organizational fit, and maturity level, and reduce implementation risks resulting from misalignment between technology and HR processes.
Abstract
Purpose: This study develops an original methodology for evaluating AI-based employee
selection systems, grounded in the AIPT maturity model (Assist–Inform–Predict–Transform),
and verifies its usefulness through a comparative analysis of two recruitment solutions
representing different technological classes.
Design/methodology/approach: The study adopts a conceptual-empirical approach.
The theoretical part draws on maturity models in management and HR, including People CMM
and HR-AIMM, as well as frameworks of algorithmic HRM. On this basis, the AIPT model
was applied to assess four levels of AI maturity in recruitment systems: operational support,
information-based decision support, prediction and recommendations, and transformation of
HR processes. The empirical part compares eRecruiter and SAP SuccessFactors Recruiting
using criteria aligned with the AIPT dimensions.
Findings: The analysis confirms the usefulness of the AIPT model for evaluating
AI applications in recruitment systems. Both systems demonstrate high maturity in the Assist
and Inform dimensions, offering automation of recruitment workflows and support for data
driven decision-making. Differences are more visible at the Predict and Transform levels,
especially in predictive functionalities, integration with HR architecture, and the extent to which
AI influences process design and user roles.
Research limitations/implications: The study is exploratory and covers only two systems,
which limits generalizability. The analysis is based mainly on vendor materials and
organizational documentation, which may create information asymmetry. Future research
should include more systems and primary data on recruitment effectiveness, decision quality,
and candidate experience.
Practical implications: The proposed methodology may support HR managers in selecting and
implementing AI-based recruitment systems by enabling a structured assessment of system
functionalities, organizational fit, and maturity level. It may also reduce implementation risks
resulting from misalignment between technology and HR processes.
Social implications: The study supports transparent and responsible implementation of AI in
recruitment, contributing to reducing algorithmic discrimination and strengthening candidate
trust.Originality/value: The originality of the study lies in integrating maturity-model logic with
a practical evaluation method for AI-based recruitment systems and demonstrating its
applicability to systems from different technological classes.
The emergence of Artificial Intelligence (AI) has transformed human resource management practices, particularly in recruitment and talent acquisition. Organizations increasingly utilize AI-powered tools such as resume screening systems, chatbots, predictive analytics, and automated candidate matching platforms to enhan...
Poonam Vijaykar, Namita Walde· International journal on res...· 0 citations
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is rapidly transforming recruitment and selection processes by enabling data-driven decision-making, automating candidate screening, and enhancing the accuracy and efficiency of talent acquisition systems. In contemporary organisations, AI-driven tools such as machine learning algorithms, c...
A. Kenku, Idowu M. Ogunkuade· Journal of Industrial and Or...· 0 citations
Artificial intelligence (AI) is increasingly used to support and automate recruitment, particularly in the IT sector, where employers receive large volumes of applications for specialised roles. This study examines the impact of AI-driven recruitment on hiring effectiveness in IT organisations in Chennai. A descriptive...
H. S., R. Ramamoorthy, A. Raman· International Journal of Res...· 0 citations
This study examines the strategic role of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in Human Resource
Management (HRM), with specific focus on human resource planning, human resource
information systems (HRIS), and employee performance evaluation. The study seeks to provide a
balanced understanding of both the opportunities and...
Geoffrey B. E. Obinna· WORLD JOURNAL OF INNOVATION...· 0 citations
This study examines the applications of artificial intelligence in recruitment and talent acquisition, with a specific focus on opportunities and ethical concerns. As organizations increasingly adopt AI-based tools for resume screening, candidate ranking, automated shortlisting, and hiring decision support, it becomes...
Rupali Singh, S. B., Usha Ranganayaki et al.· EPH – International Journal...· 0 citations
Application of artificial intelligence (AI) in human resource management (HRM) creates more efficient hiring practices, increases the engagement and productivity rates, and the performance of decision-making. his research examines the impact of AI-based talent acquisition, AI-based employee engagement, AI-driven workfo...
A. Alrifae, Sultan Eisi Madraba· Heritage and Sustainable Dev...· 0 citations
We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads.
See our Cookie Policy.