Fostering Reflective Thinking in Science Learning: An Investigation into the Impact of the Argument-Driven Inquiry Integrated STEM (ADI-STEM)
Abstract
Reflective thinking is a necessary aspect of scientific reasoning and decision making in contemporary teaching although many students fail to practice reflective thinking. The present study addressed the influence of combining the Argument-Driven Inquiry (ADI) model with Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM), which is the ADI-STEM model, on students’ reflective thinking in biotechnology learning. In a quasi-experimental study, 64 tenth graders were divided into experimental (ADI-STEM) and control (Discovery Learning) groups. Data were gathered via validated reflective thinking tests, observation sheets, and students’ responses questionnaires. The results explicit demonstrate that the ADI-STEM group achieved higher learning gains (N-Gain = 0.46) compared to the control group (N-Gain = 0.34), with the most substantial improvement observed in the ‘reacting’ indicator (N Gain = 0.67). Furthermore, the study revealed a medium effect size (d = 0.68), confirming the model’s practical effectiveness. Interdisciplinary collaboration and scientific arguments enabled students to engage in evidence-informed reflection. The main contribution of this research lies in the successful integration of Engineering Design Process (EDP) into the ADI framework, specially addressing the ‘contemplating’ level of reflection that traditional inquiry models often fail to reach. These findings support the ADI-STEM model as a power methodology for advancing reflective thinking within science education, providing a practical blueprint for educators to foster higher-order thinking through interdisciplinary inquiry.