Skip to content
Open access

Comparative Analysis of Objective Weighting Approaches in Multi-Criteria Decision Making Using WASPAS

Nov 2026 · Journal of Decision Support Systems and Multi-Criteria Decision Making · Vol 1, pp. 16-42 · 2 citations · 51 references

Abstract

Selecting the best-performing honorary employee is a multi-criteria decision-making problem because employee performance is influenced by several criteria with different levels of importance. This study aims to conduct a comparative analysis of objective weighting approaches in the Weighted Aggregated Sum Product Assessment (WASPAS) method for evaluating honorary employee performance and examining the stability of the resulting rankings. Eight alternatives, namely HE-A to HE-H, were evaluated using five criteria: Work Performance, Discipline, Cooperative Ability, Initiatives and Problem Solving, and Communication Skills. Twelve objective weighting methods, namely Entropy, G2M, RECA, LOPCOW, CRITIC, MEREC, WENSLO, LOGSTA, LODECI, ITARA, SITDE, and DAM, were independently applied to determine criterion weights. The resulting weights were then integrated into WASPAS to generate alternative rankings under different weighting scenarios. The results show that HE-F consistently achieved the first rank across all objective weighting approaches, while HE-E consistently occupied the eighth position. The ranking comparison further indicates that most methods produce ranking patterns close to the original ranking, although MEREC introduces greater changes in several alternative positions. Spearman rank correlation analysis confirms a strong consistency of the resulting rankings, with the highest correlation obtained by LODECI, SITDE, and DAM at 0.9524, followed by G2M and CRITIC at 0.9286 and MEREC at 0.9048. Overall, the findings demonstrate that the combination of objective weighting approaches and WASPAS provides a reliable framework for employee performance evaluation, while comparative correlation analysis can be used to assess ranking stability and robustness across different weighting perspectives.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access Dec 2026

Stability and robustness of decision rankings across objective weighting methods in multi-criteria decision-making

Objective weighting methods derive criterion importance directly from data, but a method producing consistent rankings across aggregation models may not be robust to weight changes. This study jointly evaluates cross-model ranking stability and perturbation robustness in multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) across fiv...

I'tishom Al Khoiry, D. Amelia · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

A Hybrid Objective Weighting and MUNRA Model for Multi-Criteria Decision-Making with Heterogeneous Data

Multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) problems often involve heterogeneous criteria with different levels of importance, making objective and consistent criterion weighting essential for reliable decision outcomes. This study proposes A Hybrid Objective Weighting and Multi-Normalized Rating Analysis (MUNRA) Model for M...

Temi Ardiansah, Ari Sulistiyawati, T. Widodo · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Comprehensive Evaluation of Distance-Based MCDM Methods Using Response to Criteria Weighting: A Ranking Stability and Sensitivity Analysis

Selecting an appropriate new store location is a complex multi-criteria decision-making problem because potential locations must be evaluated using multiple criteria with different performance characteristics. This study proposes an integrated distance-based Multi-Criteria Decision-Making framework using RECA Weighting...

S. Sumanto, Ryan Randy Suryono, Riska Aryanti et al. · 2 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Integration of Data Assessment Method Weighting and Proximity Indexed Value for Best Employee Selection in Decision Support Systems

The selection of the best employee is a multi-criteria decision-making problem because employee performance is evaluated using several criteria with different levels of importance. Subjective criterion weighting may not fully represent the characteristics of the assessment data and can influence the resulting decision....

Setiawansyah Setiawansyah, Dyah Ayu Megawaty, Faruk Ulum et al. · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Multi-Scenario Comparative Analysis of Objective Weighting Techniques in MOORA-Based Decision Support Systems

This study presents a multi-scenario comparative analysis of objective weighting techniques integrated with the MOORA method in decision support systems to evaluate their consistency, robustness, and reliability in alternative ranking. Various objective weighting methods, including WENSLO, LOGSTA, RECA, LODECI, ITARA,...

Jun-Hai Wang, Setiawansyah Setiawansyah · 0 citations
Open access

Comparative Evaluation of Ratio-Based MCDM Methods: Performance and Ranking Stability under DAM Weighting

Ratio-based Multi-Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM) methods provide practical approaches for ranking alternatives, but differences in normalization and aggregation mechanisms can produce different rankings and levels of stability. This study comparatively evaluates ratio-based MCDM methods under a common Data Assessment...

M. Takaendengan, Irma Anggraeni, F. Irawati et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.