Skip to content
Open access

Human judgement in generative AI design workflows: Managing AI dependency for creative originality and knowledge translation

Oct 2026 · Journal of Multidisciplinary & Translational Research · 0 citations · 10 references

Abstract

Generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) is increasingly being integrated into creative design workflows, enabling faster ideation, visual exploration, prototyping, and content creation. However, its increasing use also raises issues about dependence, originality and the role of human judgement in producing professional creative outcomes. This study examines design professionals’ perceptions of the risk of AI dependency in generative design processes and discusses the role of human judgement in supporting creative originality, contextual relevance and knowledge translation. This study reports a secondary thematic analysis of qualitative interview data obtained from 21 individuals working in design and AI, including junior and senior graphic designers, creative directors, digital content managers, art directors, AI developers, and an AI optimiser. The analysis re-analysed the original dissertation data with an emphasis on dependence risk, generic output, creative ownership, brand judgement, cultural sensitivity and human-led evaluation. The results suggest that AI is most helpful for low-risk, early-stage design tasks such as brainstorming ideas, exploring layouts, manipulating backgrounds, and creating fast mock-ups. However, excessive AI use led to generic production, less uniqueness, a weaker sense of creative ownership and less attention to brand, audience and cultural context. Human judgement was the core mechanism by which AI-generated outputs were understood, filtered, polished and transformed into usable design knowledge. In this work, we propose a Balanced Human-AI Knowledge Translation Framework, in which designers are active interpreters and responsible decision-makers, rather than passive users of AI-generated outputs. In the context of debates on AI-enabled innovation, this paper contributes by suggesting that the development of meaningful creative products is not simply a function of machine generation but also of human-led judgement, contextual understanding and responsible knowledge translation.

Read PDF

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.