From process to form: Foundations for a cognitive-praxic refoundation of epistemology. Concept, language, communication and understanding before representation
Oct 2026· Research, Society and Development· 0 citations· 2 references
Abstract
This theoretical article examines the Kantian theory of the concept, as reconstructed by Robert Hanna, and proposes from the standpoint of Cognitive Psychiatry an inversion of its explanatory order. The objective is to show that concept, object, unity, representation, sign, rule and understanding are late results of cognition and cannot serve as its original conditions. The method is a qualitative conceptual essay supported by a narrative review of classical sources and of studies published between 2021 and 2026. Hanna’s formulation is decomposed into six theses, each confronted with a genetic reconstruction that begins in the lived and praxic processuality in which organism and world are already causally coupled. The results describe a sequence that runs from praxis through interindividual coupling and synchronisation to objectification and formalisation, and only then reaches signification, concept, representation and propositional language. To be told to another person, lived experience has to be chewed into communicable units, which requires a model of the listener’s mind and a model of one’s own; both derive from the mother, the first verbal accompanist of the infant’s praxes, whose accompaniment, once internalised, helps to constitute the secondary self. The vocalisation “ai” in pain illustrates functional communication prior to semiosis: the sign arises when a stabilised praxis becomes decoupled from its original situation and able to evoke it. Recent developmental studies converge with this ordering. It is concluded that form does not found process; process progressively founds form, which calls for a genetic epistemology of pre-objectal, pre-formal and pre-semiotic processualities.
This theoretical article examines the relation between logos, concept, word, proposition and truth from Plato to analytic philosophy and proposes, from the standpoint of Cognitive Psychiatry, a processual reading of epistemology. The method is a qualitative conceptual essay supported by a narrative review of classical...
Giovanna Azevedo Rodrigues, M. Caixeta· Research, Society and Develo...· 0 citations
Traditional epistemology studies knowledge mainly through its formalized results, such as concepts, propositions and criteria of truth, and leaves the natural processes that precede them insufficiently explained. This article aims to propose, from the standpoint of Cognitive Psychiatry, a naturalistic and psychogenetic...
Giovanna Azevedo Rodrigues, M. Caixeta· Research, Society and Develo...· 0 citations
Modern epistemology usually examines concepts once they are already constituted, leaving unexplained how they arise and how they change while remaining recognizably the same. Objective: to propose, from Cognitive Psychiatry, a naturalistic epistemogenesis of concepts grounded in processuality. Methodology: a theoretica...
Giovanna Azevedo Rodrigues, M. Caixeta· Research, Society and Develo...· 0 citations
The law of inertia poses a privileged problem for an epistemology grounded in simple induction. As Arthur Pap observed, pure inertial motion is never met in experience; it is reached by idealization and extrapolation to a limiting case. This theoretical proposition paper argues that understanding inertia also requires...
Giovanna Azevedo Rodrigues, Marcelo Caixeta· Research, Society and Develo...· 1 citation
Objective: To propose a critique of the logical-ontological theory of the early Wittgenstein, in the Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus, which establishes a structural correspondence between world and language (the world as the totality of facts, facts as combinations of simple objects, and complex propositions as truth-fu...
Giovanna Azevedo Rodrigues, Fernando Martins Castanheira, Marcelo Caixeta· Research, Society and Develo...· 2 citations
Arthur Pap’s functional a priori explains how laws change function once knowledge is constituted, but not how the conceptual core enabling such change is formed. The aim of this article is to propose a naturogenetic theory of the genesis of knowledge, based on a re-edition of Meno’s paradox, that completes Arthur Pap’s...
Giovanna Azevedo Rodrigues, M. Caixeta· Research, Society and Develo...· 1 citation
We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads.
See our Cookie Policy.