Comparative analysis of low-temperature energy consumption and thermal management strategies for battery electric vehicles
Abstract
This paper presents a comparative analysis of two battery electric vehicles (designated Vehicle A and Vehicle B) regarding their energy consumption, driving range, and thermal management strategies under low-temperature conditions (-7°C). Based on chassis dynamometer tests following the GB/T 18386.1-2021 standard, two testing methodologies were employed: the shortened test procedure (STP) and the continuous test procedure (CCP). Under STP, Vehicle B achieved a range of 421 km with an energy consumption of 240 Wh/km, while Vehicle A reached 374 km with the same energy consumption. Under CCP, Vehicle B demonstrated improved efficiency (217 Wh/km) and an extended range of 466 km. The study further reveals fundamental differences in battery heating strategies: Vehicle A employed active battery heating using both a PTC heater and the compressor when the state of charge dropped to approximately 30%, whereas Vehicle B relied on passive thermal management without active battery heating. These findings provide quantitative insights into the trade-offs between cabin comfort, battery thermal conditioning, and overall energy efficiency in low-temperature EV operation.