Skip to content
Open access

Human or Virtual? A Study on Consumer Preferences for E‐Commerce Streamers

Sep 2026 · Journal of Consumer Behaviour · 0 citations · 58 references

TL;DR

The findings reveal that human streamers are more effective in enhancing purchase intention for utilitarian products, whereas virtual streamers demonstrate greater efficacy for hedonic products.

Abstract

With the rapid growth of live commerce, both human streamers and virtual streamers are jointly shaping the landscape of the live‐streaming industry. When selecting a streamer type, should firms opt for human streamers or virtual streamers to more effectively stimulate consumer purchase behavior? Moreover, is this effect critically moderated by product type? To address these questions, grounded in social presence theory, we conducted two scenario‐based experiments to systematically examine the interactive effect of streamer type (human vs. virtual) and product type (utilitarian vs. hedonic) on consumers' purchase intention. We further identify social presence as the underlying mediating mechanism and brand trust as a key moderator of the relationship between social presence and purchase intention. The findings reveal that human streamers are more effective in enhancing purchase intention for utilitarian products, whereas virtual streamers demonstrate greater efficacy for hedonic products. Social presence mediates this congruence effect between streamer type and product type. Furthermore, brand trust positively moderates the influence of social presence on purchase intention. This study advances a mechanism‐based account of matching between streamer type and product type in live commerce, identifying social presence as the underlying process and brand trust as a boundary condition, and offers actionable insights for firms regarding streamer selection, content design, and brand trust cultivation.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access Oct 2026

Facts or Feelings? How Virtual Streamers Reduce Consumer Uncertainty Across Product Types

Advances in artificial intelligence have accelerated the adoption of virtual streamers in live‐streaming e‐commerce. Yet the effectiveness of emotional language used by virtual streamers remains unclear in existing research. Drawing on signaling theory and a consumer‐uncertainty perspective, this study examines how v...

Kai Zhang, Biao Luo, Xiu-Zhen Weng et al. · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Entertainment Value, Streamer Trust, and Digital Customer Engagement in Live-Streaming Commerce: A Moderated PLS-SEM Analysis

Live-streaming commerce has transformed digital shopping by integrating entertainment, social interaction, and real-time communication between consumers and streamers. Although entertainment value is theoretically expected to enhance consumer engagement, the conditions under which this relationship is strengthened rema...

Andhi Febisatria, D. A. Tholibon, R. Salam et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

An Analysis of the Effectiveness of Live-Streamed Shopping on Consumers’ Impulsive Buying Behavior on Marketplaces

Live-streamed shopping has rapidly become a dominant retail format on digital marketplaces, merging real-time video broadcasting, social interaction, and instant transaction functionality within a single interface. This study analyzes the effectiveness of live-streamed shopping in shaping consumers’ impulsive buying be...

Ida Ayu Trisna Wijayanthi, Tettie Setiyarti, Ni Ketut Laswitarni · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

The impact of cultural differences on consumer purchase decisions in cross-border live streaming e-commerce

Cross-border live streaming e-commerce has emerged as a rapidly growing channel for international trade, yet the role of cultural differences in shaping consumer purchase decisions within this context has received limited empirical attention. This study investigates how cultural differences influence consumer purchase...

Huai-Li Shen · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

What Factors can Drive Consumers’ Purchase Intentions in Live Streaming e-Commerce? Evidence From China’s Segment Markets

Live streaming is a crucial marketing model in the e-commerce industry. This paper explores factors influencing the purchase intentions of middle-aged and elderly female apparels in Hengyuanxiang’s live streaming in China. Guided by the Stimulus–Organism–Response (SOR) model, the paper proposes seven stimuli, two organ...

Xiao-Li Wang, Ling Chen, Yun Liu et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

BEYOND IMPORTED CONSUMER BEHAVIOR FRAMEWORKS: A SYSTEMATIC LITERATURE REVIEW OF AUDIENCE COMMUNICATION PSYCHOLOGY IN LIVE STREAMING COMMERCE

Live streaming commerce has transformed digital commerce by integrating real-time video, streamer performance, platform affordances, audience participation, and direct purchasing functions within a single platform environment. However, existing studies have predominantly examined this phenomenon through consumer behavi...

Raditya Pratama Putra, Nathaniel Antonio Parulian · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.