NAND Flash Physical Unclonable Functions: A Comprehensive Review of Disturb Mechanisms and Extraction Strategies
Abstract
NAND flash memory has emerged as a compelling platform for intrinsic security primitives because of its widespread use, scalable architecture, and rich device-level variability. Physical unclonable functions (PUFs) derived from NAND flash exploit threshold-voltage variation, program and read disturb, soft programming and erasure, Gate-Induced Drain Leakage / Band-to-Band Tunneling (GIDL/BTBT) erase dispersion, single word-line selection ( $N_{\mathrm {WL}}=1$ ), latency, and differential current sensing to generate device-specific responses. This review provides a structured, memory-centric synthesis of NAND flash PUFs by separating physical entropy mechanisms from response-extraction strategies and comparing the reported evidence in terms of repeatability, uniqueness, uniformity, entropy, environmental robustness, extraction latency, memory wear, controller accessibility, and hardware modification. It further examines stable-cell selection, bitmap and position-map processing, aging-aware calibration, error correction, fuzzy extraction, helper-data security, and adversarial risks. The review distinguishes experiments on commercial NAND from simulation, custom-silicon, and adjacent flash implementations, and examines the architectural transition from planar floating-gate NAND to three-dimensional Vertical NAND (3D V-NAND). The available evidence shows that planar program-disturb methods currently provide the strongest support for implementation on raw commercial single-level-cell NAND, but require thousands of stress operations and low-level memory access, creating latency and endurance costs. Non-destructive threshold and differential-current approaches eliminate query write wear, while emerging 3D V-NAND paradigms leverage vertical string current isolation, Z-axis 3D array virtualization, and ground selection line ( $\text {GSL0$\mathord {-}$1}$ ) sensing to achieve gigabit-per-second key extraction with zero query wear. These findings identify the principal trade-offs and research priorities for reliable NAND-based device identification and cryptographic key reconstruction.