Skip to content
Open access

Market-Average Data Can Misrepresent Supply Chain Environmental Impacts and Their Uncertainty

Nov 2026 · Environmental Science & Technology · 0 citations · 35 references

Abstract

Market-average data sets are often used in life cycle assessment and carbon accounting when the production route of a procured good is unknown. The uncertainty this introduces is commonly characterized using generic pedigree matrix factors, which do not reflect how variability across production geographies and technologies differs between goods. Here, we develop a hybrid method that combines pedigree matrix uncertainty characterization within individual production routes with market-share-weighted Monte Carlo sampling between known production routes to represent uncertainty about which route supplied the good. We compare it with conventional market-average uncertainty analysis for 30 economically important goods. For climate impacts, conventional 5th–95th interpercentile intervals are narrower than route-weighted sampling intervals for 25 goods, at least 50% narrower for 14 goods, and up to 82% narrower. Conventional intervals exclude the central climate impact estimates of 44% of possible production routes. Route-weighted sampling captures these outcomes and reveals multimodality and impact-category-specific uncertainty profiles that conventional analysis does not. Variance decomposition distinguishes geographical and technological differences between routes from uncertainty within routes, helping prioritize supplier data collection. These differences show that conventional uncertainty estimates can mislead and may not capture how substantially initial estimates could change when supplier-specific data become available.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Preprint Sep 2026

Decision-Relevant Information in Partially Observed Production Networks

A production network can remain largely unidentified even when the economic decision it supports is identified. We characterize sufficient measurements for exposure-based decisions and compute sharp maximum regret over networks consistent with released totals. Using earlier and later vintages of Japan's interregional i...

Shao-Wen Luo, Kwok-Ping Tsang, Zi-Chao Yang · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Estimating Truck Gate Demand Under Data Scarcity: A Provenance Audit and Profile-Based Disaggregation Framework for Shuwaikh Port, Kuwait

Background: Authority-supplied daily port figures may be allocations of coarser records rather than measurements. Treating them as observed gate counts can produce spurious model accuracy. Methods: Using 365 daily container-discharge records for 2019 from the Kuwait Ports Authority (KPA), we apply four provenance diagn...

S. AlKheder, Abdulaziz Aldawish · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

A distributionally robust optimization approach for data envelopment analysis under uncertainty with an application to Chinese airports

Uncertainty is an inherent characteristic of the business environment, making it crucial to address uncertainty in data envelopment analysis (DEA) for reliable performance evaluation. In this paper, we propose a distributionally robust optimization approach to capture the underlying probability distribution of uncert...

Long-Long Shao, Hua-You Chen, Jin-Pei Liu · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Using Probability Theory to Assess and Mitigate Risks in Global Supply Chains for Internationally Traded Goods and Services

Global supply chains that support internationally traded goods and industrial services have become increasingly vulnerable to disruptions arising from geopolitical conflicts, economic uncertainty, climate-related disasters, cybersecurity threats, and transportation bottlenecks. These disruptions have exposed the limita...

M. Vasuki, A. D. Kumar, Mbonigaba Celestin et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.