Skip to content
Open access

A Lightweight Methodology for Protocol-Level Security Assessment of Smart Home Connectivity Standards: A Comparative Study of Matter, Zigbee and Z-Wave

Sep 2026 · Symposium on Intelligent Systems and Informatics · pp. 251-256 · 0 citations · 22 references

TL;DR

A lightweight protocol-level assessment methodology that characterises Matter, Zigbee and Z-Wave through multidimensional security profiles instead of a single overall ranking support a more nuanced understanding of protocol capabilities and highlight the need to complement protocol selection with product-level evaluation and operational hardening.

Abstract

Smart home ecosystems represent heterogeneous IoT environments where diverse devices, controllers, hubs and cloud services interoperate over multiple connectivity protocols. While existing comparisons of smart home standards often emphasise performance, interoperability and general security claims, fewer studies explicitly distinguish protocol-level security capabilities from implementation-dependent and operational risks. This paper proposes a lightweight protocol-level assessment methodology that characterises Matter, Zigbee and Z-Wave through multidimensional security profiles instead of a single overall ranking. The methodology defines five security dimensions – secure onboarding and commissioning, authentication and trust model, key management and cryptographic robustness, network-level attack resistance, and lifecycle and operational security – and applies a qualitative three-level scale (Strong, Moderate, Limited). Document analysis of standards, vendor documentation, and prior academic work indicates that Matter provides a more uniform protocol-level profile in authenticated onboarding, device attestation, and operational credential management, while Zigbee and Z-Wave exhibit more heterogeneous security profiles due to legacy modes, optional security features, and ecosystem constraints. The resulting security profiles support a more nuanced understanding of protocol capabilities and highlight the need to complement protocol selection with product-level evaluation and operational hardening.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access Oct 2026

EVIDENCE-INFORMED CROSS-LAYER SECURITY RECOMMENDATIONS FOR WIRELESS NETWORKS AND IOT DEVICES BASED ON PENETRATION TESTING

Smart-city and smart-home systems rely heavily on Wi-Fi, Bluetooth Low Energy, and ZigBee, while many practical risks arise from deployment and implementation weaknesses rather than failures of cryptographic primitives. This paper presents a structured, author-led synthesis of seven previously completed laboratory stud...

S. Tleuberdin, Zhandos Boranbay, K. Malakhov et al. · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Comparative Analysis of IoT Security Architectures: A Context-Aware Security–Resource Suitability Framework

A Context-Aware Security–Resource Suitability Index (SRSI), which reweights these dimensions to suit the application instead of declaring one architecture best in every case, and argues that lifecycle manageability deserves the same attention as traditional security metrics.

Dr. S. B. Sarvaiya, Vedanti C. Yawalkar, Sakshi K. · 0 citations
Book Open access Oct 2026

Beyond the Hype: Empirical Analysis of Matter Standard’s Security and Privacy

Evaluating Matter and non-Matter ecosystems shows that Matter improves security and privacy through AES-128-CCM encryption, device attestation, and secure commissioning, and its local-first design further reduces cloud dependency and limits data exposure.

Andrew Losty, Tian-Rui Hu, Daniel J. Dubois et al. · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

TrustPulse-IoT: Context-Aware Adaptive Access Control for Heterogeneous IoT Networks

TrustPulse-IoT is proposed, an adaptive security architecture that converts device identity, behavioral stability, protocol compliance, asset criticality, and telemetry freshness into a continuously refreshed trust value at the edge that can be evaluated against a baseline IoT network.

R. R. T. Pawar Pawan Appasaheb, J. Mahajan · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

METHODOLOGY FOR QUANTITATIVE SECURITY ASSESSMENT AND PRACTICAL VERIFICATION OF SMART HOME SYSTEMS PROTECTION METHODS

Topicality. The growth of the number of interconnected IoT devices in smart home systems, the heterogeneity of communication protocols, the use of cloud services, and the presence of vulnerabilities at the device, network, software, and data processing levels necessitate a quantitative assessment of the level of cybers...

A. Jabiyeva, M. Karimova, Shafag Samadova et al. · 0 citations
Conference Open access Sep 2026

Zero Trust Architecture for IoT and Smart Environments: A Systematic Literature Review

Zero Trust Architecture (ZTA) has emerged as a promising security paradigm to address the limitations of perimeter-based defenses in increasingly distributed and heterogeneous computing environments. The rapid growth of Internet of Things (IoT) and edge systems introduces challenges related to scalability, resource con...

Alvin Binoy, Shehzad S, Elfred Sebastian et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.