The Comparative Effects of Metalinguistic and Repetition Corrective Feedback on Incidental Lexical Learning: The Role of Learner Gender
Abstract
This study investigates how metalinguistic clues and repetition feedback influence incidental vocabulary learning among advanced Iranian EFL learners, with particular attention to whether learner gender moderates these effects. The study involved 45 adult participants from the Fars Business Training Centre in Shiraz, who were assigned equally to three groups of 15: a Metalinguistic Feedback group, a Repetition Feedback group, and a Control group that received no explicit corrective intervention. A 40-item multiple-choice lexical test, derived from standardized IELTS preparation materials, was administered as a pre-test. Following this baseline assessment, the 20 target vocabulary items showing the highest initial unfamiliarity were embedded in contextualized reading passages. The intervention comprised four instructional sessions over two weeks, during which oral errors involving the target items were systematically addressed using the designated feedback mode. A post-test was then administered to assess lexical gains. Data were analyzed using paired-samples t-tests, independent-samples t-tests, and one-way ANOVA in SPSS. The results showed that both metalinguistic clue feedback and repetition feedback significantly promoted incidental lexical gains from pre-test to post-test, with both experimental groups significantly outperforming the control group. However, no statistically significant difference emerged between the overall effects of the two feedback types. Furthermore, independent-samples t-tests showed that learner gender had no statistically significant main or interaction effect on incidental vocabulary learning across the groups. These findings support interactionist and cognitive SLA accounts, which suggest that prompt-based feedback mechanisms facilitate cognitive noticing and self-repair regardless of learner gender.