Skip to content
Review Open access

Investigating Patient Trust and Intention to Act in AI-Supported Clinical Decisions: Cross-Sectional Survey

Nov 2026 · Journal of Medical Internet Research · Vol 28 · 0 citations · 44 references
Medicine

TL;DR

Novel, nuanced patient preferences shaped by task and context are revealed, offering guidance for aligning AI-supported care with patient values.

Abstract

Abstract Background In health systems, AI is increasingly being implemented as a form of clinical decision support (CDS). Research on patient perspectives, however, lags behind clinician-focused studies. Before the introduction of AI-based tools, clinicians often used and continue to use rule-based guidelines and risk calculators (RCs) to inform decision-making. Prior research has shown that RCs for CDS have mixed effects on patient adherence to treatment recommendations, whereas for AI-based tools, the effect is still not clear. Objective This study aims to assess differences in patients’ behavioral intentions, trust, and preferences for clinical recommendations provided by doctors alone, doctors supported by RCs, and doctors supported by AI-based risk predictions. We also evaluate how sociodemographic characteristics affect these perceptions. Methods We surveyed 1185 US-based adults. Participants rated their likelihood of taking recommended clinical actions (behavioral intentions) across 6 clinical scenarios, where they were randomized to a different recommendation source (doctor, doctor + RC, and doctor + AI). Participants also rated their trust in the recommendation, indicated their preferred source for recommendations, and provided qualitative feedback. Results Behavioral intentions differed by recommendation source such that the doctor + RC condition had greater odds of behavioral intention than the doctor + AI condition. Behavioral intentions were also affected by the clinical condition. Participants had greater odds of trusting doctors alone over doctor + RC, and both doctors alone and doctor + RC had greater trust than doctor + AI. However, a plurality of participants ultimately preferred a doctor using an RC for making recommendations. Several sociodemographic differences were detected, namely, participants with higher subjective numeracy and literacy had higher odds of taking clinical action and higher trust across decision-support sources. We detected qualitative themes in the following categories: decision quality and reliability; trust and perceptions; patient-centeredness and autonomy; fairness, transparency, and ethics. Across categories, participants reported skepticism toward all decision sources and potential misunderstanding of AI’s ability to personalize risk predictions. Some participants also stated that they had no additional concerns or were uncertain regarding their feelings. Conclusions These findings reveal novel, nuanced patient preferences shaped by task and context, offering guidance for aligning AI-supported care with patient values. Patients were not aligned on the recommendation source across intentions, trust, and preferences. Taken together, our results indicate that patients prefer doctors working with easy-to-understand, explainable support but are still learning to trust these tools. Our findings also highlight the continued importance of the clinical context and its interaction with computer-assisted decision support. Future work should evaluate how we can transparently convey to patients the use of AI in clinical decision-making, embedded within the given clinical context. This may present an opportunity to bolster, rather than erode, patient trust.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Review Open access Oct 2026

What influences patients’ perspectives on the fairness of AI decision-making tools in healthcare? A cross sectional survey in the UK

Whilst the use of artificial intelligence (AI) in healthcare is growing, with promises that AI will reduce costs and improve efficiency, there is also concern that AI systems can perpetuate health inequalities. Prior work has explored patients’ trust in AI, but less attention has been given to how patients concep...

Elizabeth Remfry, Giulia Tomba, Michael R. Barnes et al. · 0 citations
#explainable ai Open access Oct 2026

Designing Trust, Autonomy, and Acceptance in AI-Based Clinical Decision Support Systems: A Comparative Experimental Analysis

This study integrates two experimental investigations to examine how AI-CDSS design features jointly influence trust, autonomy-related perceptions, and acceptance across patients and physicians, and demonstrates that perceived usefulness is the strongest predictor of intention to use among both patients, potential futu...

Sophia Ackerhans, C. Schultz · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Clinicians’ Trust in AI-Based Clinical Recommendations Across Controlled Primary Care–Style Clinical Vignettes: Nurse-Dominant Experimental Pilot Study

Background Safe integration of AI-enabled clinical decision support requires understanding whether users’ trust and behavioral reliance are appropriately calibrated to recommendation quality. Objective This pilot study examined a 3-item vignette-level trust construct and accept or reject behavior across sequential prim...

Avishek Choudhury, Yeganeh Shahsavar, A. P. Gurses · 0 citations
Review Open access Oct 2026

THE AI SAFETY GAP: A SCENARIO-BASED STUDY OF RISKY HEALTH DECISIONS AND MISPLACED TRUST

Artificial intelligence (AI) is becoming increasingly integrated into healthcare and everyday life, offering rapid and accessible medical information to the public. Despite its benefits, concerns remain regarding the accuracy of AI-generated medical advice and the potential risks associated with excessive reliance on t...

Adriatik Krasniqi · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

PHYSICIAN ACCOUNTABILITY IN AI-ASSISTED CLINICAL DECISIONS: A MEDICO-LEGAL PERSPECTIVE

Purpose: This study aims to examine how physician accountability (ACC) is influenced in AI-assisted clinical decision-making by investigating the role of AI reliance (AIR) and the mediating effects of explainability (EXP) and legal defensibility (LED). The study addresses a critical gap in understanding how accountabil...

Naziha Abakar Moussa · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

AI Perceptions, Professional Identity, and AI-Supported Clinical Decisions Among Medical Students and Clinicians: Cross-Sectional Survey and Quasi-Randomized Vignette Study

Background The integration of AI into health care is increasingly shaping clinical practice and decision-making. Beyond technical performance, AI has implications for professional roles, clinical reasoning, and responsibility. Understanding how medical students and clinicians perceive AI, how these perceptions relate t...

Julia-Astrid Moldt, T. Festl-Wietek, K. Nieselt et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.