The Effectiveness of PLC-HMI-Based Power Synchronization Simulation in Improving Vocational Students’ Psychomotor Learning Outcomes
Abstract
Practical learning in electrical power installation education still struggles to give students industry-oriented experiences, particularly in developing the psychomotor competencies required for complex control processes such as power synchronization. This study examined the effect of a simulation based on a programmable logic controller and human machine interface (PLC-HMI) on the psychomotor learning outcomes of vocational students in power synchronization. A quasi-experimental posttest-only nonequivalent control group design was used. The participants were 57 twelfth-grade vocational students: 29 in the experimental group, who learned with the PLC-HMI-based simulation, and 28 in the control group, who used a conventional control training kit. Psychomotor performance was assessed with a validated performance-based instrument of 13 indicators and analyzed using descriptive statistics and an independent samples t-test at a significance level of 0.05. The experimental group achieved a higher mean score of 85.07 (standard deviation 6.176) than the control group, whose mean score was 74.36 (standard deviation 7.345). The mean difference of 10.712 points was statistically significant, with an absolute t value of 5.968 and a p value below 0.001. Students who learned through the PLC-HMI-based simulation therefore showed better psychomotor performance in power synchronization, although the absence of a pretest calls for cautious interpretation. This study contributes a simulation-based learning approach that supports practical skill development and strengthens the alignment between school-based learning and industrial practice.