Skip to content
Open access

Simulating Shape Variation in Material Culture: The Simumorph R-package

Oct 2026 · Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory · Vol 34 · 0 citations · 79 references

TL;DR

A materialist view is adopted to present an alternative approach to present an alternative approach where the authors analyse purely artefact shape without the need for previous categorisation, and a simulation framework for stepwise artefactual change is developed.

Abstract

Archaeologists have devoted a significant amount of effort to define their types, or units of analysis. However, strong disagreements persist even after years of debate. This may occur for many reasons, some intrinsic to the archaeological record itself—since different technocomplexes may involve distinct and not always comparable types—and others related to the discipline’s epistemology, where interobserver bias and differences in theoretical schools and training traditions can play a key role. As a result, most archaeological analyses, usually based on type presence/absence or type frequencies, present uncertainty levels from the start, which are not always due to the archaeological record itself, but to how we analyse that record. In this work, we adopt a materialist view to present an alternative approach where we analyse purely artefact shape without the need for previous categorisation. To do this, we resort to Geometric Morphometrics, widely used in archaeology, and we develop a simulation framework for stepwise artefactual change. We provide the software tools to do this, which have been compiled in the R-package Simumorph, and we showcase its performance in four simulated archaeological scenarios. Here, we base our simulations on the geometric microliths found during the Early and Middle Holocene in the Western Mediterranean, but the framework can be applied to any context where shape variation matters.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access 2023

Multivariate Analysis in Archaeology

M. Glascock, B. MacDonald · 0 citations
Open access 2026

Ancient and Medieval Numismatics in the context of contemporary Methodological Paradigms

The paper systematizes the potential of archaeometry, X-ray fluorescence analysis, statistics of physical wear, and die modelling as instruments for reconstructing the geography of metal, the scale of coin emissions, and the dynamics of monetary circulation. Particular attention is given to the role of the “material tu...

Valerii Kapeliushnyi, Mykhailo Orlyk · 0 citations
Open access Nov 2026

Methods Matter: Assessing the Seriation Multiverse in the U.S. Southwest

As a bedrock of archaeological research, seriation and pottery dating methods have proliferated and become increasingly statistically sophisticated. Yet, rarely do archaeologists critically evaluate the effectiveness of our methods in relation to each other to ensure that results are meaningful. This study compares fou...

Donna M. Glowacki, Katherine A. Portman, Sean Field · 0 citations
Open access Nov 2026

Negative Space and Positive Form: Exhibiting Fragments in Modernity

Exhibiting archaeological material in a museum habitually involves some sort of storytelling. The remnants of the past are employed as constitutive markers in an attempting account of preceding societies and cultures. However, as the endeavour concerns foregone events, the natural temporal separation engenders an innat...

Camilla Bøgelund Poulsen · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Seriation and Joint Probability: Unifying Archaeological Dates in the Central Mediterranean, ca. 4th-1st c. BCE

Probability theory has been applied to archaeological chronology since the advent of radiocarbon dating, but key chronological indicators, such as artifact typologies, continue to be dated in descriptive terms (e.g., “in the later 3rd c. BCE”). Moreover, the informational inter-dependency for how contexts and assemblag...

S. Collins-Elliott · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.