Skip to content
Review Open access

Augmentation or erosion? Artificial intelligence and the transformation of clinical reasoning: a critical narrative review

Oct 2026 · Frontiers in Digital Health · Vol 8 · 0 citations · 48 references
Medicine

TL;DR

In the studies reviewed, AI assistance improved clinician performance in bounded detection tasks but not in open-ended diagnostic reasoning, where evidence is limited to one vignette-based trial.

Abstract

Background Artificial intelligence (AI) systems are used to support diagnosis, but a model’s accuracy does not establish that clinicians reason more accurately when they use it. This review appraises how AI decision support and large language models affect physicians’ diagnostic performance and the risks of relying on them. Methods This critical narrative review follows the Scale for the Assessment of Narrative Review Articles. Scopus, PubMed/MEDLINE, SciELO and LILACS were searched in July and August 2026 in English, Spanish and Portuguese. Eligible studies, published from 2015 onward, compared AI-assisted with unassisted clinicians, measured reliance on AI or unassisted performance after exposure to it, or externally validated deployed models. A single author selected sources purposively. Nine primary studies were appraised with an adapted Critical Appraisal Skills Programme framework. Results In randomized trials of perceptual tasks, AI support improved detection. In the MASAI mammography screening trial, cancer detection rose from 5.0 to 6.4 per 1,000 women, reading workload fell by 44%, and the interval-cancer rate was non-inferior. In colonoscopy, computer-aided detection raised the adenoma detection rate from 40.4% to 54.8%. In the only randomized trial of open-ended diagnostic reasoning, access to GPT-4 did not improve physicians’ scores (76% vs. 74%; P=.60), although the model alone scored 92%. Evidence of harm came from smaller or non-randomized studies: reader accuracy fell sharply when AI suggestions were incorrect or the AI missed a cancer; physicians trained in AI literacy were still misled by erroneous model advice; unassisted adenoma detection fell from 28.4% to 22.4% after routine AI use in one pre–post study; and a deployed sepsis model discriminated poorly on external validation (area under the curve 0.63). No eligible study from Latin America was identified. Conclusions In the studies reviewed, AI assistance improved clinician performance in bounded detection tasks but not in open-ended diagnostic reasoning, where evidence is limited to one vignette-based trial. The evidence that reliance on AI can impair performance comes from single or design-limited studies and does not establish how large or lasting such effects are. Benefit therefore cannot be inferred from model accuracy alone; assisted and unassisted clinician performance should be measured directly.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Review Open access Sep 2026

Advances in Multimodal Artificial Intelligence in Radiology: Data Integration, Foundation Models, and Clinical Applications—A Narrative Review

This narrative review examines recent technical and clinical advances in multimodal radiology AI and identifies barriers to responsible implementation, but progress in benchmark performance has outpaced evidence of safety, generalizability, and clinical utility.

G. Alfattni · 0 citations
Review Open access Nov 2026

Artificial Intelligence Versus Human Interpretation in Diagnostic Radiology: A Systematic Review of Diagnostic Accuracy and Operational Efficiency

Rising imaging workload and a shortage of radiology specialists have driven interest in artificial intelligence (AI) to improve diagnostic speed and accuracy. This systematic review, without meta-analysis, describes how AI affects diagnostic accuracy and operational efficiency compared with human interpretation in diag...

Santiago Diaz Perdomo, M. J. Losada Peña, Viviana Gutiérrez Riobamba et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

From Algorithmic Performance to Hospital Value: A Narrative Review of Clinical Artificial Intelligence

This narrative review synthesizes evidence on clinical AI methods, applications, implementation, evaluation, evaluation, and sustainability in hospitals and proposes institutional efficacy as the warranted and revisable hospital-level judgment that an AI-enabled service configuration can generate and sustain patient-ce...

Christina Morfaki · 1 citation
Review Open access Sep 2026

Artificial Intelligence Reporting Guidelines in Radiology: A Systematic Review

No single imaging-specific document comprehensively addresses model development, validation, diagnostic workflow integration, and post-deployment monitoring; complementary guidance may therefore be required.

Katarzyna Ochman, Miłosz Korbaś, Dominika Kaczyńska et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access Oct 2026

Artificial Intelligence in Neuroradiology: Diagnostic Performance, Real-World Evidence, and Transferability — A Literature Review

In 2016, Geoffrey Hinton predicted that artificial intelligence (AI) would surpass radiologists within five years and that training new ones should stop. A decade later, this review tests that prediction against the accumulated evidence. To do so, studies were identified through a structured literature search of PubMed...

Osinachi K. Okoye, A. Filatov · 0 citations
Review Open access Oct 2026

How to read a study of a diagnostic artificial intelligence tool: a narrative review and checklist for clinicians

Diagnostic tools based on artificial intelligence (AI) now read mammograms, colonoscopy video, chest radiographs, electrocardiograms and retinal photographs in routine care, yet most published evaluations are retrospective, single-centre comparisons on curated data; in one systematic review, only 2 of 83 published stud...

Abdoulrahman Elsayed Youssef Mahmoud Elnaemy, Ahmed Eldesoki · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.