A comparative study of trust-region reflective and particle swarm optimization for acoustic emission source localization in cylindrical shells including base plate sources
Abstract
This paper compares two optimization strategies for three-dimensional acoustic emission (AE) source localization in cylindrical shell structures with base plate: the trust-region reflective (TRF) method with Huber loss function and adaptive initial seeding, and particle swarm optimization (PSO). Piezoelectric sensors mounted exclusively on the cylindrical shell were used to localize pencil-lead-break sources placed on both the shell and the base plate, the latter representing a geometrically challenging case in which the wave must traverse two distinct surfaces to reach the sensors. Five detection thresholds (0.25%–5% of the peak signal voltage) were evaluated across both methods and both surface domains. Twenty repetitions were acquired at each source position, and the differences between methods were assessed with paired Wilcoxon signed-rank tests, bootstrap 95% confidence intervals, and Cliff’s delta effect sizes. For shell sources, PSO achieved the lowest average localization error (0.189 m, 95% CI [0.153,0.229] m) at a 0.5% threshold and was significantly more accurate than adaptive TRF across thresholds, a shell advantage that persists under correction for multiple comparisons. For base-plate sources the two methods were statistically comparable: their errors were nearly equal at a 1% threshold (PSO 0.079 m; adaptive TRF within 0.02 m) and each reached its lowest value at the highest threshold ( ≈0.056 m for PSO and ≈0.074 m for adaptive TRF), the paired differences being either non-significant at the mid-range thresholds or of small effect and mixed direction elsewhere. In the unrestricted localization scenario, where neither method was constrained to a surface a priori, the best results were 0.199 m (PSO, shell sources, 0.5% threshold) and 0.107 m (PSO, base sources, 1% threshold). The lowest threshold was the worst choice for both surfaces; beyond it, the optimum was surface-dependent—intermediate thresholds were best for shell sources, whereas base-plate accuracy improved toward higher thresholds. The results demonstrate that localizing AE sources on a surface not instrumented with sensors is feasible with the minimum sensor count required for three-dimensional localization, provided the geometric propagation model correctly accounts for multi-surface paths and the detection threshold is tuned to a mid-range value. With formal statistical testing, PSO emerges as the more robust single choice across both surfaces: it is clearly superior for shell localization owing to its global search capability, and at least as accurate as adaptive TRF for base-plate sources, where adaptive TRF nonetheless remains a competitive alternative.