Generation and Evaluation of CS1 Resources Implementing Latine Culture: Perspectives from Latine and Non-Latine Undergraduate Students
Abstract
Culturally-Relevant Computing (CRC) builds on culturally-relevant pedagogy by integrating students’ identities, backgrounds, and experiences into computer science instruction. CRC enhances student engagement by making learning contexts relatable, fostering concept comprehension, and boosting students’ sense of belonging. Critics argue that CRC may alienate students outside the referenced culture and potentially distract students from learning computing concepts. Most CRC research has focused on K–12 settings, leaving open questions about how CRC materials are received in higher education. This study addresses that gap by evaluating the cultural depth of five newly developed, Latine-centered CS1 learning resources with 19 undergraduate computing students (12 Latine and 7 non-Latine, i.e., in-group and out-group) using an adapted Cultural Relevance Evaluation and Assessment Tool and follow-up semi-structured interviews. Thematic analysis revealed distinct evaluative lenses: Latine students applied an experiential “insider” lens rooted in linguistic, and regional authenticity, whereas non-Latine students utilized a functional “outsider” lens prioritizing structural presentation and the logical interplay between culture and computing logic. Both groups shared a positive perception of the CRC resources, frequently highlighting cultural learning and exposure as added benefits, demonstrating a dual utility that simultaneously validates insider identity and broadens outsider perspectives. Concerns about stereotype threat were rare and largely hypothetical rather than personally felt. These findings offer evidence against concerns that culturally-grounded content alienates or distracts students, and offer design considerations, informed by both in-group and out-group perspectives, for developing culturally deep CRC resources in higher education.