Skip to content
Review Open access

Three-Dimensional Neuroanatomy Teaching: A Systematic Review Comparing Physical Models and Digital Tools

Sep 2026 · Journal of Indonesian Essential Medicines · 0 citations · 27 references

Abstract

Background: Neuroanatomy poses significat learning challenges for health professions students. Three-dimensional (3D) teaching tools, spanning physical formats (3D-printed models, plastinated brain specimens) and digital formats (virtual dissection tables [VDT], virtual reality [VR], augmented reality [AR]) are increasingly adopted. Yet comparative evidence on their educational effectiveness remains limited. Method: PubMed/MEDLINE, Google Scholar, and Garuda were systematically searched from inception to June 2026. Studies evaluating physical and/or digital 3D tools for neuroanatomy teaching in undergraduate health professions students were included. Risk of bias was assessed using the Cochrane RoB2, ROBINS-I, AXIS tool, and Newcastle-Ottawa Scales. Evidence certainty was evaluated using the GRADE framework; narrative synthesis followed SWiM guidelines. Results: Eleven studies (from 25 eligible) contributed to the synthesis, evaluating VDT (n=4), immersive VR (n=3), AR (n=1), 3D-printed models (n=2), and plastinated specimens (n=1). No included study directly compared a physical to a digital 3D tool; outcomes across categories were compared indirectly. Knowledge outcomes were inconsistent: the only RCT found VR equivalent to a paper booklet; the AR study found AR inferior to 2D cross-sections (p=0.035). Subjective engagement was universally positive. Evidence certainty was Very Low for most outcomes; the AR knowledge outcome was rated Low based on a single Moderate-RoB study. Conclusion: No 3D teaching tool demonstrates superiority over equivalent conventional instruction for neuroanatomy knowledge outcomes. VR's most credible benefit is neurophobia reduction rather than knowledge gain. Adequately powered, pre-registered randomised controlled trials directly comparing physical and digital 3D tools with active controls are needed before evidence-based curriculum recommendations can be made. Keywords: neuroanatomy; 3D teaching tools; virtual reality; medical education

Read PDF

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.