Solvent Stabilization of Protic Oxonium/Ammonium Intermediates in Cation Radical Cyclization Reactions Investigated via Computational Approaches

Abstract

Anodic intramolecular cyclization reactions have substantial synthetic utility for formation of cyclic carbon–carbon or carbon–heteroatom bonds. For cases of intramolecular trapping of a cation radical by a protic nucleophile, the cyclization step coincides with a substantial increase in substrate acidity and thus may exhibit particularly pronounced solvent effects. In this computational work, we employ both quantum chemical (QM) and quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) methods to compute solvent effects on free energy profiles for cyclization and deprotonation reaction steps for cation radical intermediates of substrates representative for anodic intramolecular cyclizations. We find substantial solvent contribution to the thermodynamic driving force for cation radical cyclization; for example, methanol and tetrahydrofuran solvents provide ∼30–35 kJ/mol driving force to form cyclic oxonium cation radicals and ∼15–25 kJ/mol driving force to form cyclic ammonium cation radicals, compared to baseline reactions in dichloromethane solvent. Given that these solvent shifts are on par with the innate cyclization reaction thermodynamics, the choice of solvent plays a crucial role in promoting/driving the cation radical cyclization step. Methanol is particularly effective at facilitating rapid deprotonation of the cyclic cation radical intermediate, which may lead to the full electrochemical process (e.g., second electron transfer) proceeding heterogeneously at the anode.