Skip to content
Book Open access

EvoHIIT: Preference-Based Selection in LLM-Assisted Evolutionary Design of Natural Language Solutions

Jul 2026 · Proceedings of the Genetic and Evolutionary Computation Conference Companion · pp. 1362-1370 · 0 citations · 31 references

TL;DR

EvoHIIT, an LLM-assisted evolutionary framework for the design of High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT) programs, is introduced, and preference-based selection mechanisms are studied to provide empirical insight into human-aligned evolution of natural language solutions.

Abstract

Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly used as generative operators in evolutionary algorithms, yet the role of selection in LLM-assisted systems remains underexplored, particularly when optimizing structured natural language artifacts without ground-truth fitness signals. We introduce EvoHIIT, an LLM-assisted evolutionary framework for the design of High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT) programs, and study preference-based selection mechanisms. Within an evolutionary loop, EvoHIIT compares four evaluation regimes: (i) scalar fitness based on LLM-predicted physiological and structural proxies, (ii) LLM-based pairwise qualitative selection, (iii) human preference selection, and (iv) hybrid strategies combining automated optimization with periodic human correction. Using schema-constrained HIIT programs as a controlled domain, we analyze convergence dynamics, mutation behavior and alignment with user and expert judgments. Our results show that the choice of selection mechanism substantially shapes search trajectories in semantic solution spaces. While proxy-based scalar fitness enables stable optimization, preference-based selection mitigates specification bias and improves perceived quality. Our findings position selection as a central design dimension in LLM-assisted evolutionary optimization and provide empirical insight into human-aligned evolution of natural language solutions.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Preprint Aug 2026

MuEvo: LLM-Driven Evolution of Multi-Heuristic Ensemble

Large language model-based automated heuristic design (LLM-AHD) has shown strong potential in discovering effective heuristics for combinatorial optimization problems. However, existing methods primarily optimize a single heuristic, whereas practical optimization frameworks often rely on multiple interacting components. Directly extending single-heuristic methods is challenging because early component selection can overlook components with late potential, while independent evolution ignores inter-component dependencies. We propose MuEvo, an LLM-driven framework for evolving heuristic ensembles under ensemble-level feedback. MuEvo combines Dynamic Component Management, which uses short-budget probing and a reversible lifecycle to revise component priorities throughout the search, with LLM-Driven Co-Evolution, which coordinates component populations through Multi-Ensemble Evaluation, Cross-Component Information Sharing, Relation-Guided Pair Evolution, and Adaptive Budget Allocation. We evaluate MuEvo on selection hyper-heuristics and componentized ant colony optimization across four combinatorial optimization domains. Results show that MuEvo consistently improves human-designed frameworks and outperforms representative multi-component extensions of state-of-the-art LLM-AHD methods, demonstrating its effectiveness across both controller-mediated heuristic pools and functionally differentiated algorithmic components.

Haoze Lv, Ning Lu, Shengcai Liu et al. · 0 citations
Preprint Aug 2026

ELMER: Evolutionary Language Model that Explores and Refines

This work introduces an Evolutionary Language Model that searches over natural-language policy descriptions and compiles typed programs for execution and shows that language can serve as a steerable, execution-grounded search representation over executable program space.

Matthew Siper, A. Khalifa, Julian Togelius · 0 citations
Preprint Jul 2026

How to Guide LLM Generation: Dual-Surrogate Guided Search for Automated Heuristic Design

Large language models (LLMs) have made automated heuristic design (AHD) increasingly practical by generating executable heuristic code from task descriptions and evaluator feedback. Yet under a limited query and evaluation budget, search efficiency depends critically on a pre-generation decision. Before each LLM query and black-box evaluation, the system must choose which archived heuristics to reuse as parents and which generation operator should transform them. Existing methods typically choose such actions with predefined rules, leaving the expected outcome of each concrete operator-parent action only indirectly modeled. Therefore, we propose \emph{\fullmethod{}} (\method{}), a surrogate-guided action-selection module for operator-parent selection in LLM-based AHD. \method{} guides the LLM code-generation process by scoring pre-generation actions with two complementary surrogates. Specifically, a transition surrogate is proposed to predict the latent distribution of the child representation induced by an operator-parent action, while an instance-conditioned utility surrogate is proposed to estimate the expected performance of sampled child latents. Moreover, we propose an uncertainty-aware acquisition rule that combines predicted utility, utility uncertainty, and transition uncertainty to select the next LLM generation action. Across a diverse heuristic-design suite, \method{} is competitive with strong LLM-AHD baselines, and ablation and action-selection analyses suggest that its behavior goes beyond simple archive ranking or fixed operator preferences.

Yuhang Wang, Chaoda Peng, Xingyu Wu et al. · 0 citations
2025

Partition to Evolve: Niching-enhanced Evolution with LLMs for Automated Algorithm Discovery

This work proposes a general LES framework that incorporates feature-assisted niche construction within abstract search spaces, enabling the seamless integration of niche-based search strategies from evolutionary computation and introduces PartEvo (Partition to Evolve), an LES method that combines niche collaborative search and advanced prompting strategies to improve algorithm discovery efficiency.

Qinglong Hu, Qingfu Zhang · 10 citations · ⚡3