Skip to content
Preprint

Advisor, Co-pilot, or Guardian? AI Role Framing and Human Decision Behavior in Automated Vehicle Takeovers

Oct 2026 · 0 citations · 115 references
Computer Science

TL;DR

Results showed that, across the three AI roles, Advisor had the shortest decision-making time, followed by Guardian and Co-pilot, followed by Advisor and Guardian.

Abstract

Artificial intelligence (AI) technology has gradually been integrated into automated vehicles. However, how this technology could systematically support takeover transitions in SAE Level 3 automated vehicles remains unknown, even though this level may remain a major form of driving automation in the near future. To address this, we implemented the three AI roles proposed by the triadic Human-AI collaboration framework (Advisor, Co-pilot, and Guardian) as potential authority-ability configurations for AI agents within an automated system. We then examined their interactions with explanation type (why and action) and directional semantics (ipsilateral and contralateral) in an automated driving simulator study with 24 participants. Results showed that, across the three AI roles, Advisor had the shortest decision-making time, followed by Guardian and Co-pilot. Advisor and Guardian were associated with higher decision-making accuracy and higher satisfaction ratings than Co-pilot. Guardian was associated with the lowest workload, followed by Advisor and Co-pilot. The effect of explanation type on decision-making time depended on AI role. Action explanations were faster under Advisor, whereas why explanations were faster under Co-pilot. For directional semantics, ipsilateral semantics were associated with shorter decision-making time than contralateral semantics. Overall, these findings provide preliminary guidance for designing AI-role authority-ability configurations and their associated speech-based takeover messages.

View source

Similar papers

#explainable ai Open access Oct 2026

Enhancing Decision-Making in Single-Pilot Operations Through Proactive and Explainable Human-Autonomy Teaming

Single-Pilot Operations (SPO) in commercial aviation raise critical safety challenges in complex, time-pressured situations where human expertise is paramount. This study investigates how AI-based Human-Autonomy Teaming (HAT) can support pilot decision-making under high workload, compromised situational awareness, and...

Charles-Alban Dormoy, T. Hentati, T. Letouzé · 0 citations
Oct 2026

Effects of AI Role and Speech Message Design on Takeover Requests in Automated Driving

AI agents that provide interpretable messages can support clearer communication between humans and automated systems in situations where drivers need to respond within a few seconds. However, the potential of these capabilities to assist drivers during the takeover process remains unknown. Therefore, this study examine...

Wei-Hsiang Lo, Jing-Yi Xie, Gao-Jian Huang · 0 citations

When Should a Human Take Back Control? Optimal Delegation under Turbulent AI Risk

When should a human take control from an autonomous AI agent, how much checking is worthwhile, and when should autonomy resume? These decisions become harder when incidents cluster and recent errors signal elevated risk. Exploratory analyses of AgentLogs coding-agent traces and ODCV-Bench task runs show higher held-out...

Hao Yan, J. Roze, Ved Upadhyay et al. · 0 citations
#explainable ai Review Open access Nov 2026

Onboard Decision-Making for AUV Autonomy: Review and Research Gaps

Onboard autonomous decision-making is a pivotal capability for Autonomous Underwater Vehicles (AUVs) operating in remote, communication-limited, and hazardous environments. This paper presents a state-of-the-art survey of decision-making architectures, examining rule-based and finite-state machines (FSMs), behavior-bas...

N. Abreu, N. Cruz · 0 citations
#human-computer interacti... Preprint Oct 2026

Human-Aware Agentic Driving: Rethinking Driver State, Trust, and Intervention

Agentic driving brings goal-directed reasoning, memory, tools, and adaptive interaction into automated vehicles. A vehicle can clarify a request, explain a maneuver, or prepare a driver to take control, then adapt its next action to the response. These capabilities make the vehicle an active participant in shaping the...

Lu Feng · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.