Comparative Analysis of Bio-Inspired Optimization Algorithms for Nonlinear PID Tuning of a Mobile Manipulator
Abstract
: This work presents a comparative study of optimization methods for tuning a nonlinear PID controller applied to trajectory tracking of a mobile manipulator. The controller combines a conventional PID structure with an error-dependent nonlinear gain, increasing tuning complexity through an additional parameter. Three bio-inspired population-based algorithms, Particle Swarm Optimization, Genetic Algorithm, and Artificial Bee Colony, were compared with a deterministic SQP-based method implemented through MATLAB’s fmincon . The tuning process used a composite objective function combining the Integral of Absolute Error, Integral of Squared Error, and Total Variation of the control signal. A three-dimensional reference trajectory, composed of a square horizontal path and sinusoidal vertical motion, was used to evaluate tracking performance. All optimized controllers followed the desired trajectory. PSO obtained the lowest objective value ( Φ opt = 0 . 955), closely followed by GA (0 . 958). SQP was the fastest method and achieved the lowest IAE (0 . 293), but the highest TVu (0 . 531). Compared with SQP, PSO reduced TVu by 21 . 3% and Φ opt by 7 . 0%. These results highlight the trade-off between tracking accuracy, control smoothness, and computational cost.