Effects of C/N ratio and carbon-source composition on nutrient removal in a dual-sludge membrane bioreactor system (A2N-MBR)
Abstract
ABSTRACT Microbial competition that is driven by substrates plays an essential role in the stable denitrifying phosphorus removal (DPR) of low carbon wastewater treatment. This paper used a dual-sludge membrane bioreactor (A2N-MBR) to evaluate C/N ratios of 3-6 using acetate, followed by a comparison of acetate, propionate and their mixture at C/N = 5. Stoichiometric analysis estimated substrate allocations among denitrifying polyphosphate-accumulating organisms (DPAOs), denitrifying glycogen-accumulating organisms (DGAOs) and denitrifying ordinary heterotrophic organisms (DOHOs), while 16S rRNA gene sequencing and Pearson correlation analysis characterised community composition and its associations with nutrient removal. At C/N = 5, stoichiometric estimates assigned 53% of anaerobic COD consumption and 82% of anoxic nitrate reduction to DPAOs, with nitrate and phosphate removal efficiencies of 76.93% and 77.00%, respectively. At C/N = 6, the estimated substrate allocations shifted towards DGAOs and DOHOs pathways. Phosphorus removal was not as consistent as nitrate removal. In the subsequent carbon source comparison at C/N = 5, the acetate propionate mixture improved reactor performance. As a result, the maximum nitrate and phosphate removal efficiencies were 91.72% and 88.50%, respectively. Correlation analysis indicated that Thauera and Zoogloea were associated with NO3--N and PO43--P removal. Conversely, Nitrospira relative abundance was negatively associated with nitrate removal. All in all, these findings link substrate conditions with community composition and DPR performance within the respective C/N and carbon source comparisons. GRAPHICAL ABSTRACTEight charts and diagrams of a wastewater reactor, showing reactors, flow paths, removal efficiencies, and microbial phylum and genus bars.The figure shows a schematic overview of a wastewater treatment study combining process diagrams and data charts. On the left, a reactor illustration connects a cylindrical feed tank to a rectangular compartmental reactor labeled A1 to A4, with arrows for influent, return sludge, excess sludge, air supply, and permeate through a membrane section. Above the reactor, three cartoon microbes are labeled DGAO, DOHO, and DPAO. On the right, six small time series charts are grouped under two titles, Removal Efficiencies at Different C slash N Ratios and Removal efficiencies with different carbon sources. Each chart plots operating time on the horizontal axis against removal percentage on the vertical axis, and several lines fluctuate across successive shaded operating stages. At the lower left, two Sankey style diagrams trace contributions of multiple microbial or functional groups from influent through reactor zones to effluent, with bands that split and merge along the flow. At the lower right, one stacked bar chart labeled phylum level and one stacked bar chart labeled genus horizontal compare relative abundances across several samples, using vertical bars subdivided into many colored segments with a legend of microbial taxa on the side. All data are approximate.