Theoretically, this study expands the taxonomy of media within the differentiation framework, while practically, the results of the analysis provide strategic recommendations for technology developers and educators in designing personalized, adaptive, and non-stigmatizing learning ecosystems.
Abstract
The diversity of student characteristics, which encompasses differences in learning readiness, interests, and cognitive profiles, poses a primary challenge in optimizing educational services across various schooling levels. Differentiated learning serves as an inclusive pedagogical approach that deliberately adapts aspects of content, process, product, and the learning environment to minimize cognitive barriers and enhance instructional effectiveness. Nevertheless, evidence-based practical guidelines regarding the implementation of adaptive learning media remain highly limited, frequently causing confusion for educational practitioners in the field. This review aims to comprehensively map the development trends of differentiated learning media innovations, both digital and non-digital, through a hybrid approach that integrates a Systematic Literature Review (SLR) and bibliometric analysis for the publication period of 2016–2025. By implementing a rigorous PRISMA protocol, a total of 14 Scopus-indexed journal articles were successfully screened and analyzed in depth. The findings reveal a massive paradigm shift toward utilizing adaptive digital ecosystems, such as hypermedia e-modules (EduHYPE-IPS), inclusive gamification platforms, as well as Smart Learning Environments based on Augmented Reality (AR) and Virtual Reality (VR). The integration of software-based initial diagnostic evaluation instruments has also proven crucial in guiding precise differentiation. Conversely, this study highlights potential psychological risks resulting from the explicit labeling of task difficulty levels, which can diminish students' self-efficacy. Theoretically, this study expands the taxonomy of media within the differentiation framework, while practically, the results of the analysis provide strategic recommendations for technology developers and educators in designing personalized, adaptive, and non-stigmatizing learning ecosystems.
One of the primary paradigms in contemporary education is student-centered learning (SCL), which emphasizes students' active participation in the learning process and the development of 21st-century skills. Research SCL in curriculum development has expanded as a result of its growing use in diverse educational settings. Nonetheless, there are still limited studies that trace the conceptual framework, intellectual growth, and research tendencies of SCL in curriculum. The purpose of this study is to map the intellectual terrain of SCL in curriculum research published from 2016 to 2025. Utilizing a bibliometric approach, data was extracted from the Scopus database using the keywords "Student-Centered Learning" and "Curriculum." VOSviewer and Microsoft Excel were employed for data analysis. Findings indicate substantial growth over the decade, with publications increasing from 28 articles in 2016 to 88 articles in 2025, alongside citations rising from 30 to 1,575. Geographically, the United States, Indonesia, and the United Kingdom represent the leading contributors, with Purdue University, Michigan State University, and Universitas Gadjah Mada as the most productive institutions. Keyword co-occurrence analysis identified three primary research domains pedagogical, curricular, and technical. Furthermore, overlay visualization reveals that themes such as artificial intelligence, online learning, critical thinking, and technology integration are emerging as dominant future trends. The findings suggest that SCL has evolved into a central paradigm in curriculum research, continuously adapting to educational changes in the digital era.
Adji W. S. Minadja, Karsoni Berta Dinata, Purnawan Nugroho et al.· Ensiklopedia Jurnal Pendidik...· 0 citations
This study aims to analyze the relationship between Computational Thinking (CT) and Digital Literacy (DL) in the context of education using a bibliometric approach combined with a Systematic Literature Review (SLR). Data were obtained from the Scopus database for the period 2020–2025 using targeted keywords and were systematically selected using the PRISMA framework. The analysis was conducted using RStudio and VOSviewer to comprehensively identify publication trends, patterns of researcher collaboration, and the development of relevant research themes. The results showed consistent publication growth, with an annual growth rate of 20.61% across 169 documents, accompanied by a significant increase in international collaboration. The synthesis of the 20 selected articles shows that CT and DL have a mutually reinforcing relationship in supporting students' development of critical thinking, problem-solving, and technological literacy. However, its implementation remains dominated in STEM and basic education, while in economic education, it remains limited, so broader, more adaptive contextual integration is needed for a sustainable future.
Deitawati Dalughu, Susanti Kurniawati, D. Disman· International Journal of Soc...· 0 citations
Higher education has been affected by significant changes due to technological advances over the past decade. These advances have positively influenced various learning approaches, especially those related to collaborative learning. This article aims to analyze the impact of the metaverse on collaborative learning in higher education, based on a systematic review of the literature following the PRISMA methodology. During the search process, inclusion and exclusion criteria were established, considering the year of publication, language, databases (WoS and Scopus), study type, and thematic area of each document examined. As a result, 23 papers were deemed suitable for review. The findings indicated that the highest scientific output occurred between 2023 and 2024. The most frequently used database for publications on this topic was Scopus, accounting for 43.47% of the total documents examined. The predominant research methodology was quantitative, representing 52.17%. Additionally, four thematic areas related to the metaverse as a mediator of collaborative learning in higher education were identified. These categories include the educational process, technology, tools, and teaching methods influenced by virtual environments. It was concluded that collaborative learning benefits significantly from the metaverse, as the virtual reality it provides creates spaces for practice and reflection for university students, offering a more engaging and collaborative learning experience.
Haydee Quispe Berrios, Maria Dolores Velasco Palacios, Zaidina Rios Quispicho et al.· Humanities and Social Scienc...· 0 citations
Analyzing current trends in science education reveals that efforts to elevate Critical Thinking Skills frequently integrate specific science learning topics alongside targeted Learning Models and Learning Media. Within this academic domain, students must move beyond mere conceptual mastery to cultivate advanced cognitive capacities, specifically analytical reasoning. Methodologically, this investigation utilized a systematic literature review supported by content analysis, harvesting peer-reviewed papers released from 2019 through 2024. Initial screening captured 200 documents, which narrowed down to 20 final publications after rigorous inclusion filtering (Prasetyo, B. and Wahyuni, 2022). Empirical results indicate that senior high school settings dominate domestic investigations regarding cognitive advancement within science learning frameworks. Physics emerges as the predominant disciplinary focus across these publications, constituting 54% of the evaluated literature. Digital platform utilization highlights Edmodo as the primary medium, recording a usage rate of 16.8%. Furthermore, discovery learning functions as the primary pedagogical framework, driving 60% of documented interventions aimed at bolstering Critical Thinking Skills. Academic contributions of this review manifest through the consolidation of contemporary data regarding effective pedagogical strategies, offering practical guidance for educators, investigators, and syllabus designers when choosing appropriate learning models and media to cultivate cognitive proficiency.
Abstract
The development of a curriculum through a contextual approach is widely recognized as an effective way to enhance students' critical thinking skills. To improve critical thinking, the contextual approach employs two main types of innovations: digital media (including augmented reality, virtual classes, and digital games) and non-digital innovations (SSCS, PBL, and Thinking Empowerment). However, debate exists on whether digital media's immersive engagement or non-digital methods' personalized, hands-on experience is more effective for delivering contextual learning and enhancing critical thinking. This study performs a meta-analysis and bibliometric analysis to assess the effectiveness of contextual learning using both digital and non-digital media in boosting critical thinking skills. Adhering to PRISMA guidelines, a literature search identified 16 studies published between 2020 and 2024 that met the inclusion criteria. These studies were analyzed using VOS-viewer to visualize research trends and SPSS for statistical tests, including ANCOVA with effect size. The Kolmogorov-Smirnov test result was 0.081 > α 0.05, Levene's test result was 0.259 > α 0.05, ANCOVA significance was 0.927 > α 0.05, and the effect size was 0.001. The findings indicate that both digital and non-digital media effectively enhance critical thinking skills, with no significant difference in their effectiveness. This implies that the choice between digital and non-digital methods should depend on factors such as accessibility, cost, and personal preference, as both approaches are equally effective for fostering critical thinking in a contextual learning environment.
Sulistyono, Maulani Pradiana, Z. Abidin· Edubiologica· 0 citations
Background of Study: Digital tools have been quickly adopted in the education field and the research on TEL has increased accordingly. Evidence on the effectiveness of digital tools in enhancing student learning outcomes, however, is still inconclusive and fragmented.Aims and Scope of Paper: The purpose of this paper is to provide a systematic review of recent empirical research in the field of the effects of digital tools on student learning outcomes in higher education. This review highlights the major research themes, summarizes the research results, and suggests future research trends of peer-reviewed studies published during the period 2019–2025.Methods: A systematic literature review was done according to PRISMA 2020. The corpus consists of 35 peer-reviewed studies from Scopus- and Association of Business Schools (ABS)-listed journals, out of 60 references. Selected studies were analyzed thematically, with a view to finding patterns and trends in the research on technology-enhanced learning.Results: Thematic clusters were identified in the review, which included: (1) learning management systems (LMS) and academic performance; (2) mobile learning and gamification technologies; (3) artificial intelligence and adaptive learning systems; and (4) collaborative digital platforms and higher-order thinking. In general, digital tools had a positive impact on students' learning outcomes, but this impact was always moderated by various factors, such as pedagogical design, teacher digital competence, student digital literacy, and the quality of the infrastructure.Conclusion: The Digital Tool – Learning Outcome Contingency Framework (DTLOCF) is proposed, and an eight-gap research agenda is presented for further research. The results suggest that digital tools are only effective for improving learning outcomes when they are used in conjunction with an effective instructional design, competent teachers, technologically literate students, and equitable technological infrastructure. The review offers recommendations for schools, school leaders and policymakers that will help them to reap the maximum benefit from digital technologies in education.
Hasan Ahmad, M. Hossain, S. Sarker· International Journal of Sus...· 0 citations
We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads.
See our Cookie Policy.
