We give a counterexample to the convergence conjecture in Remark 12 of [Bolte&Pauwels, 2021] for mini-batch stochastic approximation with definable potentials. The construction uses two convex piecewise-affine, hence semialgebraic, summands on $\mathbb{R}$. We choose a deterministic nonincreasing block stepsize sequence satisfying $\alpha_k = o(1/\log k)$ and an admissible minimum-norm selection from each aggregate batch field. On successive blocks, the iterates form lazy reflected random walks on nested dyadic lattices. An explicit endpoint-cover-time estimate, Markov's inequality, and the first Borel-Cantelli lemma imply that almost surely every sufficiently late block's iterates visit their entire lattice. Consequently, the iterates remain in $[-1,1]$ but do not converge, and their accumulation set is exactly $[-1,1]$, on which the averaged objective is constant. Finally, the construction has $\sum_k \alpha_k^2 =\infty$. Both Chat-GPT 5.6 (Sol) and Gemini Pro 3.1 (DeepThink) were used in the development and drafting of this result.
We study whole-sequence convergence of the smoothing-based full-splitting proximal subgradient method (S-FSPS) for structured nonconvex and nonsmooth fractional programs, introduced by Bo\c{t}, Li, and Tao (SIAM J. Optim., 35(4):2623--2653, 2025) as Algorithm~4.1. Existing theory guarantees only the existence of a subsequence converging to a limiting lifted stationary point. We show that this guarantee is sharp by constructing two admissible instances whose corresponding primal sequences both have cluster set $\{1\}\times\mathbb S^1$ and infinite length, although every cluster point is a limiting lifted stationary point. The construction prescribes a slowly rotating spiral and realizes it exactly through a compatible first-order jet and a $C^{1,1}$ Whitney extension. In the first instance, $A$ has rank one and every smoothing-dual iterate is nonzero. In the second, the feasible set is full-dimensional, $A$ has full row rank, and each of $f\circ K$, $g\circ A$, and the numerator $g\circ A+h$ is nonconstant on the feasible set. The first instance also yields a nonconvergent example for the corresponding variable-smoothing, single-loop, full-splitting method for nonconvex and nonsmooth composite optimization, although that method still admits a subsequence converging to an exact stationary point. Thus, a vanishing but nonsummable smoothing schedule does not imply whole-sequence convergence.
Barzilai--Borwein (BB) method has shown strong practical performance in continuous optimization, yet its convergence dynamics remains poorly understood. In particular, a central unresolved question is whether BB converges superlinearly for almost every strictly convex quadratic problem and initialization. We provide a negative answer to this question. Specifically, for every finite dimension $n\geq4$, we construct a nonempty open, hence positive-Lebesgue-measure, family of strictly convex quadratic problems and initial points for which the long Barzilai--Borwein method (BB1) converges but cannot converge root-superlinearly. More precisely, with the explicit constants $\rho_{\min}=10^{-6},\rho_{\max}=0.61$, every spectral component of the gradient is bounded above and below by the corresponding geometric sequence. Consequently, the gradient norm and the energy norm of the error satisfy two-sided geometric estimates with the same rates, while the objective gap satisfies the corresponding estimates with squared rates. In particular, all three quantities are bounded below by geometric sequences, ruling out superlinear convergence. The construction is highly nontrivial, based on a computer-assisted proof of a nonresonant, attracting seven-cycle of the projectivized BB dynamics in dimension four.
A randomized algorithm may terminate almost surely even though exceptional random tapes make it run forever. This paper studies the survival tail, the Kolmogorov complexity of one such tape, and the Hausdorff dimension of all of them. For each $s>0$ at which the powered repair matrices commute, the main theorem bounds $\sum_wP[w]^s$ over surviving prefixes $w$, uniformly over deterministic nonanticipating selectors. The case $s=1$ controls termination; the full family gives weak-source and dimension bounds. The source powers contain information absent even from the ordinary repair kernel and the complete stopping-time law. Under one common finite tape source, two overlapping disagreement-repair rules on a four-vertex path have the same ordinary kernels and the same stopping-time law for every selector, yet their nontermination dimensions can be arbitrarily close to zero and one. At one common source-power level, the same dominated tape source makes one rule run forever but gives the other an exponential stopping tail. The separation is caused by action labels that produce the same state transition and are therefore invisible at power one. For bounded-dependence $k$-SAT, conditional block min-entropy above the trace-growth threshold gives exponential termination, and the effective dimension of an individual infinite run is bounded by the trace growth induced by the clauses repaired infinitely often. Tree formulas asymptotically attain the maximum-degree dimension and global source bounds, while clique formulas attain the graph-specific one-step threshold in the stated regime. An exact backward likelihood identity complements these setwise results with tail and coding bounds for each run.
We give explicit complex polynomials $P,Q$ in three independent standard real Gaussian variables such that \[ {\mathbb E}(P^m)=0,\qquad {\mathbb E}(QP^m)=m!\neq0 \] for every $m\geq1$. In natural complex linear coordinates, $P$ has five terms and total degree $4$. Hence the Gaussian Moments Conjecture is false in every dimension $n\geq3$. We also give a six-term cubic example in four variables, which was found first and already proves failure for every $n\geq4$. Both examples follow from the same coefficient identity. The search was prompted by Levent Alp\"oge's public announcement of an explicit three-dimensional counterexample to the Jacobian Conjecture. Although the main theorem of Derksen, van den Essen, and Zhao is stated globally in dimension, its proof has fixed-dimensional content: a noninvertible cubic-homogeneous Keller map in $r$ variables forces the failure of ${\mathrm GMC}(2r)$. Tracking a standard Bass--Connell--Wright reduction of the announced map gives a conservative cubic-homogeneous counterexample in $79$ variables, and hence a route-based failure of ${\mathrm GMC}(158)$. That route is nonconstructive at the final Gaussian step and does not furnish explicit polynomials $P,Q$. The much smaller explicit failures in dimensions $4$ and $3$ below were not derived from the announced Jacobian map.
We prove weighted matroid equitability. Let $M=(E,\mathcal{I})$ be a matroid whose ground set can be partitioned into $k$ bases, and assign a nonnegative weight to every element. Then $E$ has a partition into $k$ bases such that the weights of any two bases differ by at most the largest element weight. We present two proofs based on the localized exchange theorem of Akrami, Liu, Raj, and V\'egh. The first is existential, while the second is constructive and leads to a strongly polynomial-time algorithm. As applications, we obtain an additive guarantee for matroid-constrained makespan minimization for identical machines and a strongly polynomial-time algorithm for finding an EF1 allocation under a matroid constraint and identical additive valuations. We further generalize the Beck--Fiala framework in discrepancy theory to settings with matroid constraints. Given a nonnegative matrix of column sparsity $\Delta$, we show that a fractional basis can be rounded to a basis of no larger cost while preserving every row sum within additive error $2\Delta$ times the largest matrix entry. Motivated by the $2$-sparse prefix Beck--Fiala conjecture, we formulate a conjecture on prefix-constrained matroid bases and prove a discrepancy bound $O(\log n)$. Finally, we give a counterexample to the weighted carpooling conjecture, thereby also disproving a conjecture by Morell and Skutella on single-source unsplittable flows with two-sided discrepancy bounds.
Kristóf Bérczi, Siyue Liu, Victor Reis et al.· 0 citations
We study the last iterate of the projected subGradient Method (sGM) for convex Lipschitz objectives defined on $\mathbb{R}^d$. We prove that, for a finite horizon $n$ and a constant stepsize $\eta=\Theta(1/\sqrt n)$, the last iterate achieves an optimization error of order $d/\sqrt n$, showing that the extra $\log n$ factor appearing in high dimensions is unnecessary in every fixed dimension. We complement this result with a matching linear-in-$d$ lower bound and show that the sharp worst-case dimension-horizon dependence is of order $\min\{d,\log n\}/\sqrt n$. This solves, in particular, a COLT open problem posed by Koren and Segal in 2020 and shows that the correct dependence on the dimension is linear rather than logarithmic.