Skip to content
Open access

It Does Matter. A New Framework on the Influence of Policy Evaluation

Aug 2026 · Policy Studies Journal · Vol 54 · 0 citations · 94 references

Abstract

Governments worldwide have invested heavily in policy evaluation, providing many policymakers with a steady stream of evidence into the effectiveness, efficiency, or relevance of policies. Yet, despite these investments, systematic knowledge about the actual influence of policy evaluations remains surprisingly limited. This is partly due to the insufficient conceptual differentiation of policy evaluation as a distinct type of policy advice. Building on interdisciplinary evaluation literature and public policy scholarship, the article introduces a new framework designed to enhance our understanding and categorization of the changes policy evaluations bring about in terms of policy, polity, and politics, and how these dimensions interrelate. As a parsimonious heuristic tool, the framework enables a dynamic and comprehensive assessment of the influence of policy evaluations. It contributes to the theorization of policy evaluation influence and offers insights that may inform related research on the influence of expert knowledge, policy advice, and evidence‐informed policymaking more broadly.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Conference Open access 2025

The Logic of Decision-Making in Economic Policy

As a result of empirical testing is crucial for determining which economic policy instruments align effectively with specific policy goals. However, the relationship between instruments and goals is dynamic due to fluctuating multiplier effects and variable instrument conditions. Understanding the consistency of these...

R. Gvelesiani · 0 citations
Open access 2026

The shift in classical approaches to public policy analysis: From absolute rationality to the centrality of institutions

ABSTRACT This essay provides an evolutionary analysis of how classical theoretical approaches in public policy implicitly or explicitly conceptualize institutional change. Early public policy analysis was guided by a behaviorist and rationalist perspective, which viewed change as an automatic consequence of sound, scie...

Assis Mafort Ouverney · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Strengthening international evidence-informed policy making: lessons from the Global South.

Introduction Evidence-informed policy making (EIP) has generated substantial scholarship, but its contribution to the practicalities of policy making in international organisations is limited by the focus on a discreet and generally local level of governance. Furthermore, there is an acute bias in existing EIP literatu...

J. Espey, Zhengli Huang, Giada Casarin et al. · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

The political perspective on effective approaches to evidence for policy

Abstract This paper examines how political considerations shape the use of research evidence in policy-making. It stresses that systematic and transparent approaches are essential for presenting complex issues and the best available evidence to ministers. By categorising policymakers and proposing that researchers have...

Denis Naughten · 2 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Think Globally, Act Locally: The Determinants of Local Policy Makers’ Support for Climate Policy

Although much progress to combat climate change has occurred subnationally, little research examines the policy preferences of local policy makers themselves. To address this gap, we conduct a conjoint experiment on over five hundred elected local policy makers across the United States, including mayors, county executi...

Sabrina B. Arias, J. Schwartz · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.