Comparison of large language models in the management of pediatric ureteropelvic junction obstruction: a comparative analysis of 125 clinical scenarios

İ. Baloğlu Gökçe Karlı Ali Emre Çekmece M. Özgür A. Albayrak K. Günay Mustafa Anıl Kılıç Pınar Zeytun Baloğlu K. Horasanlı

Jul 2026 · Pediatric surgery international (Print) · Vol 42 · 0 citations · 15 references

Medicine

TL;DR

ChatGPT is currently the most robust model for guideline-based management of UPJO, however, the “deceptive confidence” of models like Copilot poses a risk of misinformation and future integration should explore multimodal capabilities.

DOI PubMed Semantic Scholar

View source

Similar papers

Open access Aug 2026

Guideline Concordance of Large Language Models in the Management of Ureteral Stones: A Clinical Vignette-Based Comparative Study

The evaluated LLMs showed high concordance with EAU 2026 first-line treatment recommendations for ureteral stones, and Concordance was complete in non–priority-sensitive scenarios requiring URS prioritization.

E. D. Demirkıran · Bolu Abant Izzet Baysal Univ... · 0 citations

Open access Jul 2026

Language-dependent performance variation in large language models for dental trauma management: a comparative evaluation of ChatGPT-5.2, Gemini 3.0, and Claude 4.5 Sonnet.

This exploratory scenario-based study demonstrates model-specific, rather than universal, language effects on LLM performance in dental trauma management.

H. Öz, M. Dundar · BMC Oral Health · 0 citations

Aug 2026

Evaluation of large language models in root resorption scenarios: an ESE-aligned comparative performance assessment.

Although large language models present potential as supportive decision-making tools in the evaluation of root resorption, diagnostic inconsistencies, limitations in source accuracy, and variability in responses restrict their independent use in clinical applications, the outputs generated by these models should be int...

Öznur Küçük Keleş, Z. Arslan · Odontology : official journa... · 0 citations

Open access Aug 2026

Large language models demonstrate variable diagnostic performance and a systematic risk of undertriage in surgical triage of feline metacarpal and metatarsal fractures.

Objective To evaluate the diagnostic performance of multiple large language models (LLMs) against expert consensus in determining surgical intervention needs for feline metacarpal and metatarsal fractures. Methods In this retrospective study (December 2023 to February 2025), 73 clinical cases of feline metacarpal and...

S. Okur, Ç. Özkalıpçı, Büşra Baykal et al. · Journal of the American Vete... · 0 citations

Open access Jul 2026

The Scorecard: Comparing different scoring systems to predict the surgical outcome of pyeloplasty in children

PPS demonstrated superior predictive value for both hydronephrosis improvement and cortical gain, correlating consistently with risk stratification, in children with PUJO.

Subhan Ahmed Sajjad, S. Saulat, Jahanzeb Shaikh et al. · Pakistan journal of medicine... · 0 citations

Review Aug 2026

ChatGPT-4o as a decision-support tool in a urological tumour board: a prospective evaluation.

Final recommendation concordance did not meet the protocol-defined benchmark, ChatGPT-4o never altered an MTB decision, and clinically relevant errors occurred even among highly concordant outputs, showing that concordance alone does not guarantee safety.

J. De la Torre-Trillo, A. Munuera, M. D. Ureña et al. · Clinical and Translational O... · 0 citations