Skip to content
#software testing Open access

Combining Annotation Software to Identify Orthologous Genes (CASIO) Provides a New Dataset of Orthologous Genes for Swallowtail Butterflies

Sep 2026 · Molecular Ecology Resources · Vol 26 · 0 citations · 125 references
Medicine

TL;DR

A semi‐automated pipeline is developed and four genomic annotation methods (BRAKER2, BUSCO, Miniprot and Scipio) are compared to suggest that combining these tools can yield more accurate results in genomic research.

Abstract

ABSTRACT With the massive increase in genomic resources, it is becoming increasingly popular to analyse thousands of loci across many species. However, many of the available genomes are not annotated, which hinders an efficient search for orthologous protein‐coding genes. Here, we aim to develop a semi‐automated pipeline and compare four genomic annotation methods (BRAKER2, BUSCO, Miniprot and Scipio). Our results highlight the importance of integrating multiple annotation tools to optimise ortholog detection and improve genomic studies. Each annotation method showed different strengths. BRAKER2 annotated a substantial number of genes. BUSCO, despite limitations inherent to its reference database, identified a higher number of orthologs. Miniprot exhibited notable flexibility in accommodating diverse protein datasets, whereas Scipio successfully recovered a considerable set of genes that were not detected by the other tools. The combination of these tools allowed for more comprehensive ortholog detection. Taking advantage of this pipeline, we developed a comprehensive dataset of orthologous genes for swallowtail butterflies (Lepidoptera: Papilionidae), called Papilionidae_odb, which will facilitate future studies, especially for a non‐model group with abundant genomic data and few transcriptomic resources. We tested Papilionidae_odb by inferring a robust phylogenetic framework for Leptocircini using 142 complete genomes, which improved branch support for some phylogenetic relationships, although challenges remained in resolving relationships within certain species groups, likely due to rapid radiations. Our results highlight the complementary nature of the annotation methods and suggest that combining these tools can yield more accurate results in genomic research. This approach was implemented in a Snakemake workflow called CASIO (Combining Annotation Software to Identify Orthologous genes) and can easily be applied to other non‐model groups to improve genomic datasets in diverse taxa where transcriptomic resources are still limited.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access Sep 2026

Large-scale benchmarking of prokaryotic annotation tools across thousands of species

This study presents the first large-scale investigation of four prominent open-source annotation tools (Prokka, Bakta, EggNOG-mapper, and PGAP) across 156,033 diverse genomes, highlighting tool-specific strengths crucial for selecting optimal solutions based on genome quality, taxonomy, and origin.

Mateusz Jundzill, Martin Hölzer, S. Mangul et al. · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Scaling Functional Annotation Across Proteomes, Pangenomes and Metagenomes with Sma3s v3

The results establish Sma3s v3 as a scalable and interpretable tool for functional annotation and re-annotation of proteomes, pangenomes, and metagenomic protein catalogues.

Alejandro Rubio, Jesús L. García-Junco Alcalá, Elisa Luque-Jiménez et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

annoreport: an interactive tool for metagenome annotation

Abstract Summary Gene annotation of metagenome-assembled genomes is a critical step in determining the functional potential of microbial communities from environmental samples. However, annotation workflows using tools such as Prokka or Bakta produce per-bin output with 10 to 14 files per bin, making manual review infe...

Kepler Ridge, Byron J. Adams · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

SURE-Pipe: a pipeline to compare genomes and extract shared and unique regions

SURE-Pipe provides a robust and multipurpose framework for comparative genomics, and the outcomes can be used for species identification and the development of genome-based diagnostic approaches.

Infant Thomas, Abhishek B. Kannur, Arya Sudheer et al. · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

ProtPen Combines Sequence- and Structure-based Approaches to Facilitate Protein Function Predictions on a Proteome-wide Scale.

ProtPen is an open-source pipeline that facilitates protein function prediction by combining eggNOG-mapper for sequence-based annotation with Foldseek for rapid structural similarity searches using AlphaFold-predicted protein structures to facilitate the systemwide annotation of proteins of unknown function from proteo...

Diya Mathai, S. Schulze · 0 citations

: a database of orthologous genes from closely related prokaryotic genomes and a

The database of Alignable Tight Genomic Clusters (ATGCs) consists of closely related genomes of archaea and bacteria, and is a resource for research into prokaryotic microevolution, and provides an intuitive and efficient web interface to browse precomputed ATGCs, select appropriate ones and access ATGC-derived data.

P. Novichkov, Igor Ratnere, Y. Wolf et al. · 0 citations

Related blog posts

Microsoft Research Blog Nov 12, 2026

Microsoft Research Focus – Edition #98

What's new in research at Microsoft? Host Anson Ho explores the latest, including AI-powered universal translation, a breakthrough in a 31-year-old mathematics challenge, and advances making AI coding agents faster and more efficient.  The post Microsoft Research Focus – Edition #98 appeared first on Microsoft Research.

Microsoft Research Blog Nov 5, 2026

Formally verifying agent-written full-stack web apps with PDD Kit

AI agents can generate code at a scale that’s hard for humans to review line-by-line. PDD Kit helps ensure the code is doing what the developer intended by creating formal specifications and testing against them. It converts developer intent into a Verus specification, proves AI-generated code meets it for every input, and uses tests where proofs aren't practical. Developers review intent, not every line. The post Formally verifying agent-written full-stack web apps with PDD Kit appeared first o…

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.