Artificial Intelligence in Healthcare and Education
TL;DR
Higher education should neither ban nor normalize GenAI indiscriminately but redesign aligned teaching and assessment systems that protect independent judgment while preparing students for responsible human–AI collaboration.
Abstract
Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) has changed the conditions under which students in higher education read, write, solve problems, and complete assessed work. The central pedagogical question is therefore no longer whether students use AI, but how AI use reshapes the relationship between intended learning outcomes, teaching–learning activities, and the evidence on which judgments of competence are based. This article presents a critical narrative review that integrates constructive alignment theory with research on cognitive offloading, scaffolding, self-regulated learning, formative feedback, and assessment validity under AI-rich conditions. The review argues that GenAI can function either as a pedagogically valuable scaffold that stimulates elaboration and reflection or as a shortcut that inflates task performance without building durable competence; which pathway dominates depends on instructional design, guardrails, and the assessment formats through which learning is inferred. The review further argues that GenAI does not invalidate constructive alignment but requires its extension: intended learning outcomes must specify the conditions of performance—with or without AI—as part of the construct, and the tool environment becomes an explicit component of alignment. Building on this analysis, the article develops a design framework organized around four decisions—whether AI should be prohibited, permitted, permitted with documentation, or required for a given task—and derives implications for course design, formative feedback, and credible certification. The central conclusion is that higher education should neither ban nor normalize GenAI indiscriminately but redesign aligned teaching and assessment systems that protect independent judgment while preparing students for responsible human–AI collaboration.
This narrative review argues that the most consequential effect of GenAI is not the automation of existing teaching practices but the need to redesign curricula, learning outcomes, pedagogies, and assessment around disciplinary judgment, critical verification, intellectual independence, and transparent, ethical use of...
C. Papaneophytou, Stella A. Nicolaou· Trends in Higher Education· 0 citations
Research and policy have become good at naming the cognitive risks that generative AI (GenAI) poses to learning. Namely, detrimental cognitive offloading, metacognitive laziness, and the illusion of competence. What this literature does much less well is tell teachers what to do with that knowledge in their everyday pr...
Eva Mårell-Olsson, Tatjana Titareva· AI Policy Exchange Forum· 0 citations
This critical narrative review examines how assessment in higher engineering education should be reconceptualised when GenAI is simultaneously a learning resource, an emerging professional tool and a source of construct-irrelevant assistance and proposes a Dual-Assurance Assessment Architecture as an evidence-derived o...
Iman Farshchi· Asian Journal of Education a...· 0 citations
The paper contends that the effective integration of GenAI depends on balancing technological innovation with sound pedagogy, ethical governance, institutional readiness, and continuous professional development, and concludes that GenAI can contribute significantly to the development of inclusive, resilient, and future...
Mikael L. Chuaungo· Mizoram Educational Journal· 0 citations
It is argued that there is a need to use licensed GenAI solutions, to train educators, to redesign assessment processes, and also to develop an appropriate governance framework.
Dolantina Hyka, Elion Shabanaj, Jurgen Meçaj et al.· International Journal of Adv...· 0 citations
It is argued that process-oriented assessment offers a constructive response to generative AI by shifting attention from detecting tool use to evaluating the quality of student reasoning, and supports growth-oriented feedback that helps learners improve their learning skills and future performances.
Joshua Morrison· Intersection: A Journal at t...· 0 citations
Related blog posts
MIT News · Artificial Intelligence· news.mit.eduNov 20, 2026
An MIT and Dana-Farber Institute-led team used large language models to examine nearly 4,000 studies and hundreds of code repositories, revealing gaps in the information needed to scrutinize and reuse published research.