Skip to content

When No One Owns the Judgment: Accountability Under Contribution Dissolution in Human-AI Collaboration

Sep 2026 · 0 citations · 15 references
Computer Science

TL;DR

This work exposes the limits of disclosure rules and provenance records as responses to AI-mediated collaboration and offers three directions for discussion: distinguishing the roles AI plays, identifying judgments that require clear human ownership, and creating conditions in which AI involvement can be disclosed without default penalty.

Abstract

Communities often respond to potentially AI-assisted work by asking three questions: Was AI used? Was that use disclosed? Can hidden use be detected? These questions place AI use itself at the center of accountability while overlooking a deeper problem: unowned judgment. Evaluations, claims, decisions, and creative directions can be shaped by AI with no accountable human or institution prepared to stand behind them. We develop this argument through two illustrative cases: AI-assisted peer review and concealed AI use in creative work. The first shows how contribution dissolution can weaken responsibility while the second shows how the fear of losing credit can discourage honest disclosure. The cases expose the limits of disclosure rules and provenance records as responses to AI-mediated collaboration. We offer three directions for discussion: distinguishing the roles AI plays, identifying judgments that require clear human ownership, and creating conditions in which AI involvement can be disclosed without default penalty. The broader aim is to make AI-shaped contributions discussable, creditable, contestable, and repairable.

View source

Similar papers

#generative ai Review Sep 2026

From disclosure to verification: a risk-differentiated framework for the ethical use of AI in academic research

A risk-differentiated verification framework is developed that calibrates verification practice to the epistemic stakes of different AI uses, and argues that the property at stake is warrant: whether content has passed through a process that entitles a reader to rely on it.

A. Ünal · 0 citations
#explainable ai Review Oct 2026

Who Pays the Review Cost? Triage, Fairness, and Accountability in AI-authored Pull Requests

AIPR governance is reframe around making human judgment observable before generated contributions consume scarce reviewer attention, and conceptualize missing rationale, validation, and ownership as reviewability debt, the work reviewers must absorb when generated code lacks sufficient human grounding.

Md. Shamimur Rahman, Khairul Alam, Banani Roy et al. · 0 citations
#generative ai Open access Oct 2026

When disclosure rules are not enough: authorial warrant and judgment in ai-supported scholarship

Editorial policies increasingly require authors to disclose substantive uses of generative AI, but such requirements commonly focus on whether, where, and how a model was used. Even function-specific disclosure may locate a model in the research or writing process without showing how its outputs entered scholarly judgm...

M. Mirończuk · 0 citations
Oct 2026

Knowledge on trial: AI, trust and the future of decision-making

The purpose of the paper is to highlight that while they may be in a hurry to feed the growing giant of AI, they must also thoughtfully consider the consequences. The black-box nature of AI raises concerns about transparency and trust and as long as they do not fully understand how AI reaches its conclusions, quest...

Saleeq Ahmad Dar, Hilal Ahmad Dar · 0 citations
Book Open access Nov 2026

When Does AI Disclosure Build Trust? The Effects of Transparency Depth and Human Oversight on Reliance on AI Advice

A basic AI label reveals that AI was involved but says little about how the resulting advice was produced or reviewed. This study tests a first-stage moderated mediation model in which transparency messages relate to self-reported willingness to follow AI-mediated financial advice through perceived trustworthiness, con...

F. Situmeang, Nick de Ridder · 0 citations
Nov 2026

Who holds the judgment? Agentic AI, vendor custody, and the accountability gap

It is concluded that effective agentic AI governance requires clearer delegation boundaries, custodial transparency, mandatory disclosure obligations, and independent verification, and these principles provide a practical framework for institutional procurement and accountability.

Ashley Y. Shin, Donghee Shin · 0 citations

Related blog posts

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.