Skip to content
Review Open access

UNDERSTANDING ENGLISH TEACHERS’ KNOWLEDGE OF DEEP LEARNING INSTRUCTION IN INDONESIAN EFL CLASSROOMS

Aug 2026 · SECONDARY: Jurnal Inovasi Pendidikan Menengah · Vol 6, pp. 2424-2439 · 0 citations

Abstract

Indonesia’s adoption of deep learning as the pedagogical orientation of its national curriculum places teachers at the centre of efforts to translate mindful, meaningful, and joyful learning into English language teaching practice. This study explores what English teachers know about deep learning instruction and how their knowledge shapes their reported practice. A qualitative case study was conducted in a single state Islamic senior secondary school, MAN 1 Garut, West Java. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews with two purposively selected English teachers. To strengthen the trustworthiness of the findings and reduce interpretive subjectivity, the data were systematically analysed using reflexive thematic analysis involving coding, theme development and review, and the tracing of interpretations back to the empirical data. The small number of participants was treated as a feature of the case study design, allowing in-depth examination of teachers’ experiences and reasoning within a specific context rather than statistical generalisation. The findings show that teachers’ knowledge of deep learning was unevenly developed. Although the three pillars were recognised terminologically, mindful learning was interpreted differently and did not fully correspond to the metacognitive meaning emphasised in policy discourse. In contrast, teachers demonstrated relatively strong procedural knowledge through their use of contextual, collaborative, and engagement-oriented teaching practices. The main finding is a gap between teachers’ ability to enact practices consistent with deep learning and their ability to articulate the theoretical principles underlying those practices. Participation in professional training had also not fully strengthened teachers’ confidence in identifying their existing practices as deep learning. These findings suggest that deep learning is being assimilated into teachers’ existing pedagogical repertoires rather than substantially reorganising them. Professional development should therefore strengthen principled knowledge by using teachers’ own successful practices as starting points for reflection and connecting those practices to explicit learning principles. ABSTRAK Penerapan pembelajaran mendalam (deep learning) sebagai orientasi pedagogis kurikulum nasional Indonesia menempatkan guru sebagai aktor penting dalam menerjemahkan konsep pembelajaran yang penuh perhatian, bermakna, dan menyenangkan ke dalam praktik pembelajaran bahasa Inggris. Studi ini bertujuan mengeksplorasi pengetahuan guru bahasa Inggris tentang pengajaran pembelajaran mendalam dan bagaimana pengetahuan tersebut membentuk praktik yang mereka laporkan. Penelitian menggunakan studi kasus kualitatif yang dibatasi pada satu sekolah menengah atas negeri Islam, yaitu MAN 1 Garut, Jawa Barat. Data diperoleh melalui wawancara semi-terstruktur dengan dua guru bahasa Inggris yang dipilih secara purposif. Untuk menjaga keterpercayaan temuan dan mengurangi subjektivitas interpretasi, data dianalisis secara sistematis menggunakan analisis tematik reflektif dengan proses pengodean, peninjauan tema, dan penelusuran keterkaitan antara data empiris dan interpretasi penelitian. Keterbatasan jumlah partisipan diposisikan sebagai karakteristik desain studi kasus yang memungkinkan eksplorasi mendalam terhadap pengalaman dan penalaran guru dalam konteks tertentu, bukan sebagai dasar generalisasi statistik. Hasil penelitian menunjukkan bahwa pengetahuan guru tentang pembelajaran mendalam bersifat tidak merata. Ketiga pilar pembelajaran dikenali secara terminologis, tetapi konsep mindful learning ditafsirkan secara berbeda dan belum sepenuhnya dipahami dalam pengertian metakognitif yang ditekankan dalam kebijakan. Sebaliknya, pengetahuan prosedural guru relatif kuat, terlihat dari kemampuan menerapkan berbagai praktik pembelajaran kontekstual, kolaboratif, dan berorientasi pada keterlibatan siswa. Temuan utama menunjukkan adanya kesenjangan antara kemampuan guru dalam menerapkan praktik yang mendukung pembelajaran mendalam dan kemampuan mereka menjelaskan prinsip teoretis yang mendasari praktik tersebut. Bahkan, pengalaman mengikuti pelatihan belum sepenuhnya membangun keyakinan guru dalam mengidentifikasi praktiknya sebagai pembelajaran mendalam. Temuan ini menunjukkan bahwa pembelajaran mendalam cenderung diasimilasi ke dalam repertoar pedagogis yang telah dimiliki guru, sehingga pengembangan profesional perlu diarahkan pada penguatan pengetahuan berprinsip melalui refleksi terhadap praktik nyata guru dan pengaitan praktik tersebut dengan prinsip pembelajaran yang eksplisit.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Review Open access Sep 2026

STUDENTS’ PERCEPTIONS OF USING DEEPL APPLICATION IN LEARNING ENGLISH AT THE ENGLISH DEPARTMENT OF UNIVERSITAS BHINNEKA PGRI

ABSTRACT The increasing integration of artificial intelligence (AI) into English language education has transformed how students engage with translation and academic learning. Among AI-powered translation tools, DeepL has gained attention for its contextual accuracy and natural language output. However, limited studies...

Alifia Amada Permata Putri, Moh. Choirul Huda, A. Septiana · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Lost in Translation: Students’ Experiences of ELT Policy and Classroom Practice

This study aims to explore how secondary school students perceive the implementation of the latest English Language Teaching (ELT) practices under the Merdeka Curriculum in Indonesia, particularly in relation to communicative language teaching and student-centred learning. To address the research objectives, this study...

T. Efendi · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Building English Literacy Through Mall and Deep Learning: Challenges and Needs of Elementary School English Teachers

Objective: This study analyzes the challenges and needs of elementary school teachers in the southern coastal areas of Central Java and the Special Region of Yogyakarta in teaching English reading and writing, and identifies the need to develop a digital learning model based on Mobile Assisted Language Learning (MALL)...

Puspa Dewi, Titi Anjarini, Edi Sunjayanto Masykuri · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Filipino Teachers’ Experiences in Contextualizing Grammar Instruction for EFL Learners in Thailand

This study examined how English grammar teaching has evolved towards more contextualized methods to improve communication skills. However, challenges remain in EFL settings like Thailand, where exposure to English is limited. Even with a notable number of Filipino teachers in the Thai education system, research on how...

Jonil Macalam, Esperval Cezhar Cadillac · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Technology-Supported Deep Learning in Indonesian EFL Classrooms: Teachers’ Strategies and Learners’ Experiences

Deep learning has become an increasingly popular topic in the literature as a solution to Indonesia's surface-level learning outcomes. However, little is known about how teachers turn this pedagogical approach into everyday, technology-mediated EFL practice. Using a qualitative multiple-case study design, this study ex...

Hanif Maulaniam Sholah, B. Cahyono, Anik Nunuk Wulyani et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.