Written corrective feedback (WCF) is widely used to promote second language (L2) writing accuracy, but research on translanguaging in feedback has focused predominantly on peer or oral feedback. Little is known about whether planned translanguaging in teacher-provided written corrective feedback can enhance learners' engagement with feedback and subsequent writing accuracy. This exploratory study therefore examined whether strategically integrating Arabic and English into teacher-provided WCF was associated with greater feedback adoption and more favorable immediate and delayed accuracy development than English-only WCF.
The study employed an exploratory classroom-based pre-test/post-test/delayed post-test quasi-experimental design involving 70 first-year Saudi EFL university students at CEFR B1 level, assigned through two intact classes to a translanguaging condition (
n
= 36) or an English-only condition (
n
= 34). Both groups received direct WCF with metalinguistic explanations targeting subject–verb agreement, the English article system, and cohesive markers. In the translanguaging condition, Arabic and English were strategically interwoven, with English used for corrected forms and Arabic used primarily for complex explanations and crosslinguistic reasoning. Feedback adoption was measured through learners' revisions, while writing accuracy was operationalized as the proportion of erroneous obligatory contexts. Accuracy was assessed at pre-test, immediate post-test, and delayed post-test; 55 students completed all three assessments.
The translanguaging group adopted a significantly greater proportion of feedback in revision than the English-only group (M = 0.81 vs. 0.68,
p
= .006), with the difference driven primarily by cohesive-marker feedback. Among the 55 completers, the translanguaging group's overall error rate declined from 0.49 at pre-test to 0.22 at post-test and 0.16 at delayed post-test, whereas the English-only group's rate increased from 0.40 to 0.45 and 0.49, respectively. The Test Time × Group interaction was significant (
p
< .001). Baseline-adjusted analyses also showed lower overall error rates for the translanguaging group at both the immediate and delayed post-tests. Target-specific analyses indicated significant advantages for articles and cohesive markers at the immediate post-test and for subject–verb agreement, articles, and cohesive markers at the delayed post-test.
The findings provide preliminary evidence that planned translanguaging in teacher-provided WCF may facilitate feedback adoption and support more favorable short- and longer-term accuracy trajectories, particularly for discourse-level features and forms requiring crosslinguistic explanation. However, because the intervention involved only one class per condition and the groups differed at baseline, the findings should be interpreted as exploratory associations rather than definitive causal effects. Multi-cluster or randomized replications are needed to determine whether the observed advantages can be attributed specifically to translanguaging WCF.
This study investigated whether hybrid (ChatGPT-generated and teacher-provided) feedback could yield greater gains in grammatical accuracy than teacher-only feedback among on-site A2-level English as a foreign language (EFL) students at a technical higher education institute in Quito, Ecuador. A six-week quasi-experi...
Rony Monteros Campues, Alexis Contreras-Falcones· Frontiers in Education· 0 citations
The distinct impacts of direct and indirect written corrective feedback (WCF) on writing skills have been extensively explored in English as a foreign language (EFL) teaching, yielding mixed results. Prior research has underscored the suitability of indirect WCF for students with high English proficiency, leaving the b...
Funda Ölmez Çağlar, Gonca Nur Ölmez· Kuramsal Eğitimbilim· 0 citations
Although pedagogical translanguaging has gained increasing attention in multilingual education, little is known about how learners perceive teacher-provided translanguaging written corrective feedback (WCF) compared with conventional English-only WCF.
This mixed-methods study investigated the perceptions a...
Fahad Aldosari· Frontiers in Education· 0 citations
While research in instructed second language acquisition (ISLA) emphasizes the positive impact of corrective feedback (CF) in improving L2 pronunciation skills, teachers often provide feedback inconsistently and focus primarily on segmental, word‐level issues. This is usually associated with either lack of training o...
This study aims to identify the written corrective feedback (WCF) strategies employed by lecturers in an Academic English Writing course and to describe how these strategies are implemented in students’ written work. The research problem arises from the limited understanding of how lecturers select and apply corrective...
Nurhayati Nurhayati, S. Dollah, Nurdin Noni et al.· Berkala Ilmiah Pendidikan· 0 citations
Written corrective feedback (WCF) is a cornerstone of second language (L2) writing instruction, and the emergence of AI-based tools has substantially transformed its delivery. However, a critical conceptual distinction exists between AI tools that provide corrective feedback on linguistic form, such as Grammarly and Ca...
Luiza Marabyan, Lilit Avetisyan, Marine Avetisyan et al.· Technology in Language Teach...· 1 citation
We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads.
See our Cookie Policy.