Comparative Numerical Simulation on Heat Transfer Performance of CO2 and Water in Closed-Cycle Geothermal Development Systems

Abstract

Driven by China’s “Dual Carbon” strategy, medium-deep closed-loop geothermal energy has become a mainstream clean heating technology owing to the advantage of “heat extraction without groundwater production”. However, its large-scale application is restricted by low single-well heat output and an unclear matching mechanism between working fluids and wellbores. Taking sandstone geothermal reservoirs in Dezhou, Northwestern Shandong Depression, as the research object, a 3D coupled heat transfer model of the wellbore–reservoir was established via COMSOL Multiphysics. The heat transfer characteristics of water and CO2 under variable injection temperature, mass flow rate and wellbore layout were compared. The results show that: (1) injection temperature dominates the heat extraction performance of water, which matches branched wells and delays overall reservoir thermal depletion during long-term exploitation; (2) CO2 performance is highly sensitive to mass flow rate and suitable for connected wells, and an asymmetric geothermal field with “cooled injection zone and heated production zone” forms under a high flow rate; (3) limited by low specific heat capacity, CO2 delivers lower heat power at an identical flow rate, while equivalent heat yield can be achieved when its flow rate doubles that of water. This study clarifies matched development schemes for two working fluids and provides a theoretical reference for optimized exploitation of closed-loop geothermal systems in sandstone reservoirs in Northwestern Shandong.