Simulation-Based Evaluation of Energy-Constrained Quantum-Classical Competition
TL;DR
It is discovered that the energy benefits of quantum computing economies are contingent on large-scale computation, and quantum computing may represent a more sustainable pathway for the computing industry.
Abstract
This paper develops a simulation-based framework for evaluating the energy implications of quantum and classical computing firms competing in a market with limited energy resources. We model providers as differentiated Cournot competitors whose feasible service capacity is induced by technology-specific energy scaling laws: polylogarithmic for quantum algorithms that achieve an equivalent computational target and polynomial for classical emulation. For symmetric groups of quantum and classical firms, the equilibrium reduces to a tractable two-equation system that supports large scenario sweeps over market size, technology mix, and hardware coefficients. We characterize the capacity-constrained Nash equilibrium, prove the existence of a demand scale beyond which quantum service becomes more energy efficient, and report numerical experiments calibrated to trapped-ion and Rydberg platforms. The results identify when quantum energy advantage is only asymptotic and when it becomes operationally relevant.
